arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv cs/0606079cs.DL
收藏

开放获取增长的十年跨学科比较及其如何增加研究引文影响

Ten-Year Cross-Disciplinary Comparison of the Growth of Open Access and How it Increases Research Citation Impact

C. Hajjem, S. Harnad, Y. Gingras

摘要:

Lawrence(2001)发现,在Web上可公开访问(OA)的计算机科学文章被引用的次数更多。我们在物理学中复制了这一点。我们测试了12年(1992-2003)中发表的1,307,038篇文章,涉及10个学科(生物学,心理学,社会学,健康,政治学,经济学,教育,法律,商业,管理)。机器人使用参考元数据ISI引文数据(信号可检测性d '= 2.45;偏差= 0.52)在Web上搜索全文。OA(相对于OA + NOA总数)文章的百分比从5%-16%不等(取决于学科,年份和国家),并且每年缓慢攀升(相关性r= 0.76,样本量N=12,概率p < 0.005)。比较OA和NOA在同一期刊/年度的文章,OA文章的引用率一直较高,按学科和年份的优势从36%-172%不等。比较六个引用范围内的文章(0,1,2-3,4-7,8-15,16+引用),OA文章的年百分比在每个引用范围内的增长速度明显快于NOA(r > .90,N=12,p < .0005),并且随着引用次数的增加,影响更大(r = .98,N=6,p < .005)。因果关系无法从这些数据中确定,但我们之前在物理学中发现了类似的模式,其中OA百分比要高得多(甚至在某些子领域接近100%),这使得OA引用优势不太可能仅仅是或主要是自我选择偏差(只让自己更好的文章OA)。进一步的研究将分析效果的时间,因果成分和与其他变量的关系。

英文摘要:

Lawrence (2001)found computer science articles that were openly accessible (OA) on the Web were cited more. We replicated this in physics. We tested 1,307,038 articles published across 12 years (1992-2003) in 10 disciplines (Biology, Psychology, Sociology, Health, Political Science, Economics, Education, Law, Business, Management). A robot trawls the Web for full-texts using reference metadata ISI citation data (signal detectability d'=2.45; bias = 0.52). Percentage OA (relative to total OA + NOA) articles varies from 5%-16% (depending on discipline, year and country) and is slowly climbing annually (correlation r=.76, sample size N=12, probability p < 0.005). Comparing OA and NOA articles in the same journal/year, OA articles have consistently more citations, the advantage varying from 36%-172% by discipline and year. Comparing articles within six citation ranges (0, 1, 2-3, 4-7, 8-15, 16+ citations), the annual percentage of OA articles is growing significantly faster than NOA within every citation range (r > .90, N=12, p < .0005) and the effect is greater with the more highly cited articles (r = .98, N=6, p < .005). Causality cannot be determined from these data, but our prior finding of a similar pattern in physics, where percent OA is much higher (and even approaches 100% in some subfields), makes it unlikely that the OA citation advantage is merely or mostly a self-selection bias (for making only one's better articles OA). Further research will analyze the effect's timing, causal components and relation to other variables.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑