研究资助总是有益的吗?2014-2020年英国研究的跨学科分析
Is Research Funding Always Beneficial? A Cross-Disciplinary Analysis of UK Research 2014-20
AI总结:
本研究基于英国REF 2021的113,877篇文章数据,发现受资助研究在所有领域总体质量更高,资助不可或缺,且引文不适用于评估人文社科的资助研究质量。
摘要:
寻找和管理外部资助如今占据了研究人员大量宝贵的时间。尽管资助对某些类型的研究至关重要,对其他研究也有益处,但它也可能限制学术选择和创造力。因此,评估其是否会产生不利影响或并非必要十分重要。在此,我们调查受资助的研究是否在所有领域和所有主要研究资助机构中均倾向于具有更高质量。基于英国卓越研究框架(REF)2021中涵盖所有领域的113,877篇文章的同行评审质量评分,我们估计受资助期刊文章的比例存在显著的学科差异,从神学与宗教研究(16%+)到生物科学(91%+)不等。结果表明,在剔除研究团队规模的影响后,受资助研究总体上可能具有更高质量,这适用于所有最大的研究资助机构和所有领域。然而,不同资助机构所支持研究的平均质量存在差异。资助似乎在健康相关领域尤为有益。研究结果未显示因果关系,也未考虑所获资助的金额,但与资助能提高研究质量,或是由高质量研究人员或项目获得资助的情况相符。总之,没有任何广泛的研究领域与资助无关,因此没有哪个领域可以忽视它。结果还表明,在艺术与人文及大多数社会科学中,引文不是评估研究资助时研究质量的有效代理指标。
英文摘要:
The search for and management of external funding now occupies much valuable researcher time. Whilst funding is essential for some types of research and beneficial for others, it may also constrain academic choice and creativity. Thus, it is important to assess whether it is ever detrimental or unnecessary. Here we investigate whether funded research tends to be higher quality in all fields and for all major research funders. Based on peer review quality scores for 113,877 articles from all fields in the UK's Research Excellence Framework (REF) 2021, we estimate that there are substantial disciplinary differences in the proportion of funded journal articles, from Theology and Religious Studies (16%+) to Biological Sciences (91%+). The results suggest that funded research is likely to be higher quality overall, for all the largest research funders, and for all fields, even after factoring out research team size. There are differences between funders in the average quality of the research they support, however. Funding seems particularly beneficial in health-related fields. The results do not show cause and effect and do not take into account the amount of funding received but are consistent with funding either improving research quality or being won by high quality researchers or projects. In summary, there are no broad fields of research in which funding is irrelevant, so no fields can afford to ignore it. The results also show that citations are not effective proxies for research quality in the arts and humanities and most social sciences for evaluating research funding.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。