arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2211.06203cs.CY
收藏

人工智能与自动化决策风险监管的规范挑战

Normative Challenges of Risk Regulation of Artificial Intelligence and Automated Decision-Making

Karlsruhe Institute of Technology(卡尔斯鲁厄理工学院);University of Heidelberg(海德堡大学)

Carsten Orwat, Jascha Bareis, Anja Folberth, Jutta Jahnel, Christian Wadephul

AI总结:

本文探讨了人工智能与自动化决策风险监管中的规范挑战,分析了基本权利和社会价值观的模糊性及其对风险评估的影响,并提出通过科学和政治辩论来解决规范性选择问题。

摘要:

近期有关监管人工智能(AI)和自动化决策(ADM)的提议提出了一种特定形式的风险监管,即基于风险的方法。最显著的例子是欧洲委员会提出的《人工智能法案》(AIA)。本文探讨了风险监管中出现的挑战,这些挑战主要源于特定类型的风险,即对基本权利和基本社会价值观的保护风险。这些挑战主要源于在解释、具体化或操作化基本权利和社会价值观时的规范模糊性。这在(1)人类尊严、(2)信息自主权、数据保护和隐私、(3)公正和公平、(4)共同福祉等方面得到了体现。规范模糊性要求规范性选择,这些选择在所提出的AIA中由不同主体分配。特别关键的规范性选择包括选择规范性观念以具体化风险、聚合和量化风险,包括使用指标、平衡价值冲突、设定可接受风险水平以及标准化。为了避免缺乏民主合法性和法律不确定性,建议进行科学和政治辩论。

英文摘要:

Recent proposals aiming at regulating artificial intelligence (AI) and automated decision-making (ADM) suggest a particular form of risk regulation, i.e. a risk-based approach. The most salient example is the Artificial Intelligence Act (AIA) proposed by the European Commission. The article addresses challenges for adequate risk regulation that arise primarily from the specific type of risks involved, i.e. risks to the protection of fundamental rights and fundamental societal values. They result mainly from the normative ambiguity of the fundamental rights and societal values in interpreting, specifying or operationalising them for risk assessments. This is exemplified for (1) human dignity, (2) informational self-determination, data protection and privacy, (3) justice and fairness, and (4) the common good. Normative ambiguities require normative choices, which are distributed among different actors in the proposed AIA. Particularly critical normative choices are those of selecting normative conceptions for specifying risks, aggregating and quantifying risks including the use of metrics, balancing of value conflicts, setting levels of acceptable risks, and standardisation. To avoid a lack of democratic legitimacy and legal uncertainty, scientific and political debates are suggested.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑