arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1909.01095cs.CY
收藏

界定AI法规的适用范围

Defining the scope of AI regulations

Jonas Schuett

AI总结:

本文批评以“AI”术语界定法规范围,提出基于风险的监管路径,通过界定技术方法、应用和能力三类风险来源提升法律定义的明确性与适用性。

摘要:

本文主张,AI法规的实质适用范围不应依赖“人工智能(AI)”这一术语。论证过程如下:首先提出法律定义应满足的若干要求,随后梳理现有的AI定义,并讨论这些定义在多大程度上符合所提出的要求。研究表明,现有AI定义未能满足法律定义最重要的要求。接着,本文认为基于风险的方法更为可取。政策制定者不应使用AI这一术语,而应聚焦于他们希望降低的具体风险。研究表明,通过界定相关风险的主要来源,可以更好地满足法律定义的要求:某些技术方法(例如强化学习)、应用(例如人脸识别)以及能力(例如与物理环境进行交互的能力)。最后,本文讨论了该方法在多大程度上也可应用于更先进的AI系统。

英文摘要:

The paper argues that the material scope of AI regulations should not rely on the term "artificial intelligence (AI)". The argument is developed by proposing a number of requirements for legal definitions, surveying existing AI definitions, and then discussing the extent to which they meet the proposed requirements. It is shown that existing definitions of AI do not meet the most important requirements for legal definitions. Next, the paper argues that a risk-based approach would be preferable. Rather than using the term AI, policy makers should focus on the specific risks they want to reduce. It is shown that the requirements for legal definitions can be better met by defining the main sources of relevant risks: certain technical approaches (e.g. reinforcement learning), applications (e.g. facial recognition), and capabilities (e.g. the ability to physically interact with the environment). Finally, the paper discusses the extent to which this approach can also be applied to more advanced AI systems.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑