定义人工智能模型和人工智能系统:解决边界问题的框架
Defining AI Models and AI Systems: A Framework to Resolve the Boundary Problem
AI总结:
本文通过分析896篇学术论文和80多份监管文件,提出人工智能模型与系统的定义框架,解决边界问题,明确责任分配。
摘要:
新兴的人工智能监管规定对不同角色有不同义务(例如,欧盟AI法案区分了AI模型和AI系统的提供者和部署者),但“人工智能模型”和“人工智能系统”基础术语缺乏清晰一致的定义。通过系统回顾896篇学术论文和手动审查超过80份监管、标准和技术或政策文件,我们分析了现有定义的不同概念视角。然后追溯定义的渊源和范式转变,发现大多数标准和监管定义源自OECD的框架,这些框架在发展过程中加剧了概念模糊性。人工智能模型和系统之间的边界模糊性导致在确定不同角色的义务时遇到实际困难,并引发某些修改是否专属于模型还是非模型系统组件的问题。我们提出了基于模型和系统本质及其关系的概念定义,然后为现代神经网络机器学习AI开发了操作定义:模型由训练参数和架构组成,而系统由模型加上额外组件组成,包括处理输入和输出的接口。最后,我们讨论了监管实施的含义,并检验我们的定义如何在理论场景和真实世界事件的案例研究中解决责任分配中的模糊性。
英文摘要:
Emerging AI regulations assign distinct obligations to different actors along the AI value chain (e.g., the EU AI Act distinguishes providers and deployers for both AI models and AI systems), yet the foundational terms "AI model" and "AI system" lack clear, consistent definitions. Through a systematic review of 896 academic papers and a manual review of over 80 regulatory, standards, and technical or policy documents, we analyze existing definitions from multiple conceptual perspectives. We then trace definitional lineages and paradigm shifts over time, finding that most standards and regulatory definitions derive from the OECD's frameworks, which evolved in ways that compounded rather than resolved conceptual ambiguities. The ambiguity of the boundary between an AI model and an AI system creates practical difficulties in determining obligations for different actors, and raises questions on whether certain modifications performed are specific to the model as opposed to the non-model system components. We propose conceptual definitions grounded in the nature of models and systems and the relationship between them, then develop operational definitions for contemporary neural network-based machine-learning AI: models consist of trained parameters and architecture, while systems consist of the model plus additional components including an interface for processing inputs and outputs. Finally, we discuss implications for regulatory implementation and examine how our definitions contribute to resolving ambiguities in allocating responsibilities across the AI value chain, in both theoretical scenarios and case studies involving real-world incidents.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。