arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2601.04094cs.CYcs.AIcs.HC
收藏

浴缸、边界与沙盒:法律不确定性下的人工智能监管学习

Bathtubs, Boundaries, and Sandboxes: AI Regulatory Learning under Legal Uncertainty

Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology(卢森堡科学技术研究院);University of Luxembourg(卢森堡大学)

Tom Deckenbrunnen, Alessio Buscemi, Marco Almada, Alfredo Capozucca, German Castignani

AI总结:

本文以《人工智能法案》为例,运用Coleman的浴缸模型分析AI治理中的监管学习空间,论证法律不确定性无法完全事前消除且对监管学习必要,并探讨边界对象与边界协商工件如何将法律要求转化为操作实践。

摘要:

有效监管人工智能是一项决定性的政策挑战,源于其融入社会的各个方面。为了对其快速发展和涌现特性保持响应,全球政策制定者依赖高层次原则和抽象的法律要求。然而,这种灵活性虽然支持了面向未来的以人为本的监管并使其与社会伦理价值观保持一致,但也导致了下游的法律不确定性,因为开发者、公司和审计人员在将这些抽象要求转化为可验证的技术要求时面临困难。本文以《人工智能法案》为例,利用Coleman的浴缸模型分析AI治理中的监管学习空间。它论证了法律不确定性无法完全事前消除,并且在合理范围内,它对于监管学习也是必要的,因为它为关于社会技术意义的边界协商创造了空间。基于这一分析,本文展示了边界对象和边界协商工件如何帮助解释法律要求向操作实践的转化。通过考察技术沙盒框架,本文进一步确定了技术基础设施必须具有的具体属性,以便在AI评估中作为边界协商工件有效运作。本文得出结论,法律确定性仍然是长期目标,但过早关闭监管工具有可能破坏适应性治理所需的学习过程。

英文摘要:

Effective regulation of AI is a defining policy challenge, driven by their integration into all aspects of society. To remain responsive to their rapid development and emergent properties, policymakers across the globe rely on high-level principles and abstract legal requirements. Yet, while this flexibility supports future-proofing human-centred regulations and aligning them with socio-ethical values, it also causes legal uncertainty downstream as developers, companies, and auditors struggle with translating these abstract requirements into verifiable technical requirements. Using the AI Act as an example, this paper draws on Coleman's bathtub to analyse the regulatory learning space in AI governance. It argues that legal uncertainty cannot be fully reduced ex ante and that, within reasonable bounds, it is also necessary for regulatory learning because it creates the space in which boundary negotiation over socio-technical meaning can occur. Building on this analysis, the paper shows how boundary objects and boundary negotiating artifacts help explain the translation of legal requirements into operational practice. By examining technical sandbox frameworks, it further identifies concrete properties that technical infrastructures must possess to function effectively as boundary negotiation artifacts in AI assessment. The paper concludes that legal certainty remains the long-term aim, but that premature closure of regulatory instruments risks undermining the learning processes needed for adaptive governance.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑