arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2407.05336cs.AIcs.CY
收藏

公共部门中的人工智能、理性化与控制的限度:税收政策优化案例

Artificial intelligence, rationalization, and the limits of control in the public sector: the case of tax policy optimization

Oxford Internet Institute, University of Oxford(牛津大学牛津互联网研究院);Center for Information Technology Policy, Princeton University(普林斯顿大学信息技术政策中心);Center for Advanced Study in the Social Sciences, Stanford University(斯坦福大学社会科学高等研究中心)

Jakob Mokander, Ralph Schroeder

AI总结:

本文以AI优化税收政策、减少经济不平等的思想实验为例,基于韦伯理性化理论揭示AI治理对多元政治价值、非工具性义务与人的自我决定的冲击,并指出科学只能提供手段而不能规定目的。

摘要:

人工智能(AI)在公共部门中的使用,最好被理解为长期存在的理性化和官僚化进程的延续与强化。借鉴韦伯,我们将这些进程的核心视为以工具理性取代传统,即以最可计算、最高效的方式实现任何既定政策目标。本文中,我们论证了公众和学界针对AI系统的诸多批评,如何源于韦伯式理性化核心处众所周知的张力。为说明这一点,我们引入一个思想实验:利用AI系统优化税收政策,以推进减少经济不平等这一特定规范性目的。分析表明,建立一个促进社会和经济平等的机器般的税收体系是可能的。然而,这也凸显出AI驱动的政策优化:(i)以排斥其他相互竞争的政治价值为代价;(ii)压倒公民对彼此所负有的非工具性义务感;(iii)削弱人作为自我决定存在者的观念。当代旨在确保AI系统合法、合乎伦理且安全的学术研究和倡议,建立在并强化了支撑理性化进程的核心假设,包括现代观念——科学能够扫除压迫性制度,并以理性统治取而代之,从而将人类从道德不义中拯救出来。这过于乐观。科学只能提供手段,不能规定目的。尽管如此,AI在公共部门中的使用也可能有益于自由民主制的制度和过程。最重要的是,AI驱动的政策优化要求规范性目的被明确化和形式化,从而使其接受公众的审视和辩论。

英文摘要:

The use of artificial intelligence (AI) in the public sector is best understood as a continuation and intensification of long standing rationalization and bureaucratization processes. Drawing on Weber, we take the core of these processes to be the replacement of traditions with instrumental rationality, i.e., the most calculable and efficient way of achieving any given policy objective. In this article, we demonstrate how much of the criticisms, both among the public and in scholarship, directed towards AI systems spring from well known tensions at the heart of Weberian rationalization. To illustrate this point, we introduce a thought experiment whereby AI systems are used to optimize tax policy to advance a specific normative end, reducing economic inequality. Our analysis shows that building a machine-like tax system that promotes social and economic equality is possible. However, it also highlights that AI driven policy optimization (i) comes at the exclusion of other competing political values, (ii) overrides citizens sense of their noninstrumental obligations to each other, and (iii) undermines the notion of humans as self-determining beings. Contemporary scholarship and advocacy directed towards ensuring that AI systems are legal, ethical, and safe build on and reinforce central assumptions that underpin the process of rationalization, including the modern idea that science can sweep away oppressive systems and replace them with a rule of reason that would rescue humans from moral injustices. That is overly optimistic. Science can only provide the means, they cannot dictate the ends. Nonetheless, the use of AI in the public sector can also benefit the institutions and processes of liberal democracies. Most importantly, AI driven policy optimization demands that normative ends are made explicit and formalized, thereby subjecting them to public scrutiny and debate.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑