arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2210.17218cs.CYcs.AIcs.HCcs.LGcs.SYeess.SY
收藏

政府中的人工智能:概念、标准与统一框架

Artificial intelligence in government: Concepts, standards, and a unified framework

Alan Turing Institute(阿兰·图灵研究所);University of Bath(巴斯大学);University of Oxford(牛津大学)

Vincent J. Straub, Deborah Morgan, Jonathan Bright, Helen Margetts

AI总结:

本文通过整合性文献综述识别并聚类69个AI多学科关键术语,提出运行适配性、认识论对齐和规范性偏离三个新概念,构建AI-GOV概念类型学并与技术测量标准相连接,以统一政府中AI的研究框架。

摘要:

人工智能(AI)的最新进展,尤其是生成式语言建模方面的进展,有望推动政府变革。鉴于新型AI系统具备先进能力,关键在于将其嵌入标准操作程序、明确的认识论标准,并使其行为符合社会的规范性期望。随后,多个领域的学者开始对AI应用可能呈现的不同形式进行概念化,既强调其潜在益处,也指出其潜在缺陷。然而,相关文献仍然较为分散,公共管理与政治学等社会科学学科的研究者,与AI、机器学习(ML)和机器人学等快速发展的领域,都在相对孤立地发展各自的概念。尽管已有呼声要求将政府中AI的新兴研究正式化,但目前仍缺乏一种能够涵盖理解将AI嵌入公共部门背景所产生后果所需的完整理论视角深度的均衡论述。在此,我们通过首先开展一项整合性文献综述,识别并聚类在AI多学科研究中频繁共现的69个关键术语,从而统一社会科学与技术学科之间的研究努力。随后,我们基于该文献计量分析的结果,提出三个新的多层面概念,用于以更统一的方式理解和分析面向政府的AI系统(AI-GOV):(1)运行适配性,(2)认识论对齐,以及(3)规范性偏离。最后,我们将这些概念付诸实践,将其作为AI-GOV概念类型学中的维度,并将每个维度与新兴的AI技术测量标准相连接,以鼓励可操作化、促进跨学科对话,并激发那些旨在借助AI重新思考政府的人们之间的辩论。

英文摘要:

Recent advances in artificial intelligence (AI), especially in generative language modelling, hold the promise of transforming government. Given the advanced capabilities of new AI systems, it is critical that these are embedded using standard operational procedures, clear epistemic criteria, and behave in alignment with the normative expectations of society. Scholars in multiple domains have subsequently begun to conceptualize the different forms that AI applications may take, highlighting both their potential benefits and pitfalls. However, the literature remains fragmented, with researchers in social science disciplines like public administration and political science, and the fast-moving fields of AI, ML, and robotics, all developing concepts in relative isolation. Although there are calls to formalize the emerging study of AI in government, a balanced account that captures the full depth of theoretical perspectives needed to understand the consequences of embedding AI into a public sector context is lacking. Here, we unify efforts across social and technical disciplines by first conducting an integrative literature review to identify and cluster 69 key terms that frequently co-occur in the multidisciplinary study of AI. We then build on the results of this bibliometric analysis to propose three new multifaceted concepts for understanding and analysing AI-based systems for government (AI-GOV) in a more unified way: (1) operational fitness, (2) epistemic alignment, and (3) normative divergence. Finally, we put these concepts to work by using them as dimensions in a conceptual typology of AI-GOV and connecting each with emerging AI technical measurement standards to encourage operationalization, foster cross-disciplinary dialogue, and stimulate debate among those aiming to rethink government with AI.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑