We consider the Subset Sum Ratio Problem ($SSR$), in which given a set of integers the goal is to find two subsets such that the ratio of their sums is as close to~1 as possible, and introduce a family of variations that capture additional meaningful requirements. Our main contribution is a generic framework that yields fully polynomial time approximation schemes (FPTAS) for problems in this family that meet certain conditions. We use our framework to design explicit FPTASs for two such problems, namely Two-Set Subset-Sum Ratio and Factor-$r$ Subset-Sum Ratio, with running time $\mathcal{O}(n^4/\varepsilon)$, which coincides with the best known running time for the original $SSR$ problem [15].
We present new, faster pseudopolynomial time algorithms for the $k$-Subset Sum problem, defined as follows: given a set $Z$ of $n$ positive integers and $k$ targets $t_1, \ldots, t_k$, determine whether there exist $k$ disjoint subsets $Z_1,\dots,Z_k \subseteq Z$, such that $Σ(Z_i) = t_i$, for $i = 1, \ldots, k$. Assuming $t = \max \{ t_1, \ldots, t_k \}$ is the maximum among the given targets, a standard dynamic programming approach based on Bellman's algorithm [Bell57] can solve the problem in $O(n t^k)$ time. We build upon recent advances on Subset Sum due to Koiliaris and Xu [Koil19] and B…
In the field of algorithmic analysis, one of the more well-known exercises is the subset sum problem. That is, given a set of integers, determine whether one or more integers in the set can sum to a target value. Aside from the brute-force approach of verifying all combinations of integers, several solutions have been found, ranging from clever uses of various data structures to computationally-efficient approximation solutions. In this paper, a unique approach is discussed which builds upon the existing min-heap solution for positive integers, introducing a tree-based data structure influence…
The Subset-Sums Ratio problem (SSR) is an optimization problem in which, given a set of integers, the goal is to find two subsets such that the ratio of their sums is as close to 1 as possible. In this paper we develop a new FPTAS for the SSR problem which builds on techniques proposed in [D. Nanongkai, Simple FPTAS for the subset-sums ratio problem, Inf. Proc. Lett. 113 (2013)]. One of the key improvements of our scheme is the use of a dynamic programming table in which one dimension represents the difference of the sums of the two subsets. This idea, together with a careful choice of a scali…
The subset sum problem, also referred as SSP, is a NP-Hard computational problem. SSP has its applications in broad domains like cryptography, number theory, operation research and complexity theory. The most famous algorithm for solving SSP is Backtracking Algorithm which has exponential time complexity. Therefore, our goal is to design and develop better alternate enumeration techniques for faster generation of SSP solutions. Given the set of first n natural numbers which is denoted by Xn and a target sum S, we propose various alternate enumeration techniques which find all the subsets of Xn…
For high volume data streams and large data warehouses, sampling is used for efficient approximate answers to aggregate queries over selected subsets. Mathematically, we are dealing with a set of weighted items and want to support queries to arbitrary subset sums. With unit weights, we can compute subset sizes which together with the previous sums provide the subset averages. The question addressed here is which sampling scheme we should use to get the most accurate subset sum estimates. We present a simple theorem on the variance of subset sum estimation and use it to prove variance optimalit…
Given a multiset $S$ of $n$ positive integers and a target integer $t$, the subset sum problem is to decide if there is a subset of $S$ that sums up to $t$. We present a new divide-and-conquer algorithm that computes all the realizable subset sums up to an integer $u$ in $\widetilde{O}\!\left(\min\{\sqrt{n}u,u^{4/3},σ\}\right)$, where $σ$ is the sum of all elements in $S$ and $\widetilde{O}$ hides polylogarithmic factors. This result improves upon the standard dynamic programming algorithm that runs in $O(nu)$ time. To the best of our knowledge, the new algorithm is the fastest general algorit…
In the Equal-Subset-Sum problem, we are given a set $S$ of $n$ integers and the problem is to decide if there exist two disjoint nonempty subsets $A,B \subseteq S$, whose elements sum up to the same value. The problem is NP-complete. The state-of-the-art algorithm runs in $O^{*}(3^{n/2}) \le O^{*}(1.7321^n)$ time and is based on the meet-in-the-middle technique. In this paper, we improve upon this algorithm and give $O^{*}(1.7088^n)$ worst case Monte Carlo algorithm. This answers the open problem from Woeginger's inspirational survey. Additionally, we analyse the polynomial space algorithm for…
Reducing the conditions under which a given set satisfies the stipulations of the subset sum proposition to a set of linear relationships, the question of whether a set satisfies subset sum may be answered in a polynomial number of steps by forming, solving, and constraining a series of linear systems whose dimensions and number are both polynomial with respect to the length of the set. Given its demonstrated 100% accuracy rate and its demonstrable justification, this algorithm may provide basis to reconsider the validity of SSP-based and NP-hard-reliant cryptosystems.
Given a multiset $S$ of $n$ positive integers and a target integer $t$, the Subset Sum problem asks to determine whether there exists a subset of $S$ that sums up to $t$. The current best deterministic algorithm, by Koiliaris and Xu [SODA'17], runs in $\tilde O(\sqrt{n}t)$ time, where $\tilde O$ hides poly-logarithm factors. Bringmann [SODA'17] later gave a randomized $\tilde O(n + t)$ time algorithm using two-stage color-coding. The $\tilde O(n+t)$ running time is believed to be near-optimal. In this paper, we present a simple and elegant randomized algorithm for Subset Sum in $\tilde O(n + t…
Given a set (or multiset) S of n numbers and a target number t, the subset sum problem is to decide if there is a subset of S that sums up to t. There are several methods for solving this problem, including exhaustive search, divide-and-conquer method, and Bellman's dynamic programming method. However, none of them could generate universal and light code. In this paper, we present a new deterministic algorithm based on a novel data arrangement, which could generate such code and return all solutions. If n is small enough, it is efficient for usual purpose. We also present a probabilistic versi…
Given $N$ instances $(X_1,t_1),\ldots,(X_N,t_N)$ of Subset Sum, the AND Subset Sum problem asks to determine whether all of these instances are yes-instances; that is, whether each set of integers $X_i$ has a subset that sums up to the target integer $t_i$. We prove that this problem cannot be solved in time $\tilde{O}((N \cdot t_{max})^{1-ε})$, for $t_{max}=\max_i t_i$ and any $ε> 0$, assuming the $\forall \exists$ Strong Exponential Time Hypothesis ($\forall \exists$-SETH). We then use this result to exclude $\tilde{O}(n+P_{max} \cdot n^{1-ε})$-time algorithms for several scheduling problems…
Approximating Subset Sum is a classic and fundamental problem in computer science and mathematical optimization. The state-of-the-art approximation scheme for Subset Sum computes a $(1-\varepsilon)$-approximation in time $\tilde{O}(\min\{n/\varepsilon, n+1/\varepsilon^2\})$ [Gens, Levner'78, Kellerer et al.'97]. In particular, a $(1-1/n)$-approximation can be computed in time $O(n^2)$. We establish a connection to Min-Plus-Convolution, a problem that is of particular interest in fine-grained complexity theory and can be solved naively in time $O(n^2)$. Our main result is that computing a $(1-1…
We consider the canonical Subset Sum problem: given a list of positive integers $a_1,\ldots,a_n$ and a target integer $t$ with $t > a_i$ for all $i$, determine if there is an $S \subseteq [n]$ such that $\sum_{i \in S} a_i = t$. The well-known pseudopolynomial-time dynamic programming algorithm [Bellman, 1957] solves Subset Sum in $O(nt)$ time, while requiring $Ω(t)$ space. In this paper we present algorithms for Subset Sum with $\tilde O(nt)$ running time and much lower space requirements than Bellman's algorithm, as well as that of prior work. We show that Subset Sum can be solved in $\tilde…
Given $(a_1, \dots, a_n, t) \in \mathbb{Z}_{\geq 0}^{n + 1}$, the Subset Sum problem ($\mathsf{SSUM}$) is to decide whether there exists $S \subseteq [n]$ such that $\sum_{i \in S} a_i = t$. There is a close variant of the $\mathsf{SSUM}$, called $\mathsf{Subset~Product}$. Given positive integers $a_1, ..., a_n$ and a target integer $t$, the $\mathsf{Subset~Product}$ problem asks to determine whether there exists a subset $S \subseteq [n]$ such that $\prod_{i \in S} a_i=t$. There is a pseudopolynomial time dynamic programming algorithm, due to Bellman (1957) which solves the $\mathsf{SSUM}$ an…
Given n positive integers, the Modular Subset Sum problem asks if a subset adds up to a given target t modulo a given integer m. This is a natural generalization of the Subset Sum problem (where m=+\infty) with ties to additive combinatorics and cryptography. Recently, in [Bringmann, SODA'17] and [Koiliaris and Xu, SODA'17], efficient algorithms have been developed for the non-modular case, running in near-linear pseudo-polynomial time. For the modular case, however, the best known algorithm by Koiliaris and Xu [Koiliaris and Xu, SODA'17] runs in time O~(m^{5/4}). In this paper, we present an …
A major goal in the area of exact exponential algorithms is to give an algorithm for the (worst-case) $n$-input Subset Sum problem that runs in time $2^{(1/2 - c)n}$ for some constant $c>0$. In this paper we give a Subset Sum algorithm with worst-case running time $O(2^{n/2} \cdot n^{-γ})$ for a constant $γ> 0.5023$ in standard word RAM or circuit RAM models. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first improvement on the classical ``meet-in-the-middle'' algorithm for worst-case Subset Sum, due to Horowitz and Sahni, which can be implemented in time $O(2^{n/2})$ in these memory models. Our …
This article details the algorithmics in FLSSS, an R package for solving various subset sum problems. The fundamental algorithm engages the problem via combinatorial space compression adaptive to constraints, relaxations and variations that are often crucial for data analytics in practice. Such adaptation conversely enables the compression algorithm to drain every bit of information a sorted superset could bring for rapid convergence. Multidimensional extension follows a novel decomposition of the problem and is friendly to multithreading. Data structures supporting the algorithms have trivial…
This paper introduces a deterministic algorithm for solving an instance of the Subset Sum Problem based on a new method entitled the Bipartite Synthesis Method. The algorithm is described and shown to have worst-case limiting performance over similar to the best deterministic algorithms achieving run time complexity on the order of O(2^0.5n). This algorithm is representative of a more expansive capability that might convey significant advantages over existing deterministic or probabilistic methods, and it is amenable to blending with existing methods. The method introduced can be applied to a …
Given a set $Z$ of $n$ positive integers and a target value $t$, the Subset Sum problem asks whether any subset of $Z$ sums to $t$. A textbook pseudopolynomial time algorithm by Bellman from 1957 solves Subset Sum in time $O(nt)$. This has been improved to $O(n \max Z)$ by Pisinger [J. Algorithms'99] and recently to $\tilde O(\sqrt{n} t)$ by Koiliaris and Xu [SODA'17]. Here we present a simple randomized algorithm running in time $\tilde O(n+t)$. This improves upon a classic algorithm and is likely to be near-optimal, since it matches conditional lower bounds from Set Cover and k-Clique. We th…
Subset sum is a very old and fundamental problem in theoretical computer science. In this problem, $n$ items with weights $w_1, w_2, w_3, \ldots, w_n$ are given as input and the goal is to find out if there is a subset of them whose weights sum up to a given value $t$. While the problem is NP-hard in general, when the values are non-negative integer, subset sum can be solved in pseudo-polynomial time $~\widetilde O(n+t)$. In this work, we consider the dynamic variant of subset sum. In this setting, an upper bound $\tmax$ is provided in advance to the algorithm and in each operation, either a n…
We consider the Modular Subset Sum problem: given a multiset $X$ of integers from $\mathbb{Z}_m$ and a target integer $t$, decide if there exists a subset of $X$ with a sum equal to $t \pmod{m}$. Recent independent works by Cardinal and Iacono (SOSA'21), and Axiotis et al. (SOSA'21) provided simple and near-linear algorithms for this problem. Cardinal and Iacono gave a randomized algorithm that runs in $O(m \log m)$ time, while Axiotis et al. gave a deterministic algorithm that runs in $O(m \text{ polylog } m)$ time. Both results work by reduction to a text problem, which is solved using a dyn…
Subset Sum is a classical optimization problem taught to undergraduates as an example of an NP-hard problem, which is amenable to dynamic programming, yielding polynomial running time if the input numbers are relatively small. Formally, given a set $S$ of $n$ positive integers and a target integer $t$, the Subset Sum problem is to decide if there is a subset of $S$ that sums up to $t$. Dynamic programming yields an algorithm with running time $O(nt)$. Recently, the authors [SODA '17] improved the running time to $\tilde{O}\bigl(\sqrt{n}t\bigr)$, and it was further improved to $\tilde{O}\bigl(n…
We present a new FPTAS for the Subset Sum Ratio problem, which, given a set of integers, asks for two disjoint subsets such that the ratio of their sums is as close to $1$ as possible. Our scheme makes use of exact and approximate algorithms for the closely related Partition problem, hence any progress over those -- such as the recent improvement due to Bringmann and Nakos [SODA 2021] -- carries over to our FPTAS. Depending on the relationship between the size of the input set $n$ and the error margin $\varepsilon$, we improve upon the best currently known algorithm of Melissinos and Pagourtzi…
We study the problem of computing an ensemble of multiple sums where the summands in each sum are indexed by subsets of size $p$ of an $n$-element ground set. More precisely, the task is to compute, for each subset of size $q$ of the ground set, the sum over the values of all subsets of size $p$ that are disjoint from the subset of size $q$. We present an arithmetic circuit that, without subtraction, solves the problem using $O((n^p+n^q)\log n)$ arithmetic gates, all monotone; for constant $p$, $q$ this is within the factor $\log n$ of the optimal. The circuit design is based on viewing the su…
Knapsack and Subset Sum are fundamental NP-hard problems in combinatorial optimization. Recently there has been a growing interest in understanding the best possible pseudopolynomial running times for these problems with respect to various parameters. In this paper we focus on the maximum item size $s$ and the maximum item value $v$. We give algorithms that run in time $O(n + s^3)$ and $O(n + v^3)$ for the Knapsack problem, and in time $\tilde{O}(n + s^{5/3})$ for the Subset Sum problem. Our algorithms work for the more general problem variants with multiplicities, where each input item comes …
From a high volume stream of weighted items, we want to maintain a generic sample of a certain limited size $k$ that we can later use to estimate the total weight of arbitrary subsets. This is the classic context of on-line reservoir sampling, thinking of the generic sample as a reservoir. We present an efficient reservoir sampling scheme, $\varoptk$, that dominates all previous schemes in terms of estimation quality. $\varoptk$ provides {\em variance optimal unbiased estimation of subset sums}. More precisely, if we have seen $n$ items of the stream, then for {\em any} subset size $m$, our sc…
In the subset sum problem we are given n positive integers along with a target integer t. A solution is a subset of these integers summing to t. In this short note we show that for a given subset sum instance there is a proof of size $O^*(\sqrt{t})$ of what the number of solutions is that can be constructed in $O^*(t)$ time and can be probabilistically verified in time $O^*(\sqrt{t})$ with at most constant error probability. Here, the $O^*()$ notation omits factors polynomial in the input size $n\log(t)$.
We show that Nederlof's algorithm [Information Processing Letters, 118 (2017), 15-16] for constructing a proof that the number of subsets summing to a particular integer equals a claimed quantity is flawed because: 1) its consistence is not kept; 2) the proposed recurrence formula is incorrect.
In the Subset Sum problem we are given a set of $n$ positive integers $X$ and a target $t$ and are asked whether some subset of $X$ sums to $t$. Natural parameters for this problem that have been studied in the literature are $n$ and $t$ as well as the maximum input number $\rm{mx}_X$ and the sum of all input numbers $Σ_X$. In this paper we study the dense case of Subset Sum, where all these parameters are polynomial in $n$. In this regime, standard pseudo-polynomial algorithms solve Subset Sum in polynomial time $n^{O(1)}$. Our main question is: When can dense Subset Sum be solved in near-lin…
Solving random subset sum instances plays an important role in constructing cryptographic systems. For the random subset sum problem, in 2013 Bernstein et al. proposed a quantum algorithm with heuristic time complexity $\widetilde{O}(2^{0.241n})$, where the "$\widetilde{O}$" symbol is used to omit poly($\log n$) factors. In 2018, Helm and May proposed another quantum algorithm that reduces the heuristic time and memory complexity to $\widetilde{O}(2^{0.226n})$. In this paper, a new quantum algorithm is proposed, with heuristic time and memory complexity $\widetilde{O}(2^{0.209n})$.
Subset-Sum and k-SAT are two of the most extensively studied problems in computer science, and conjectures about their hardness are among the cornerstones of fine-grained complexity. One of the most intriguing open problems in this area is to base the hardness of one of these problems on the other. Our main result is a tight reduction from k-SAT to Subset-Sum on dense instances, proving that Bellman's 1962 pseudo-polynomial $O^{*}(T)$-time algorithm for Subset-Sum on $n$ numbers and target $T$ cannot be improved to time $T^{1-\varepsilon}\cdot 2^{o(n)}$ for any $\varepsilon>0$, unless the Stro…
We study the computational complexity of one of the particular cases of the knapsack problem: the subset sum problem. For solving this problem we consider one of the basic variants of the Branch-and-Bound method in which any sub-problem is decomposed along the free variable with the maximal weight. By the complexity of solving a problem by the Branch-and-Bound method we mean the number of steps required for solving the problem by this method. In the paper we obtain upper bounds on the complexity of solving the subset sum problem by the Branch-and-Bound method. These bounds can be easily comput…
In this paper, we study the subset-sum problem by using a quantum heuristic approach similar to the verification circuit of quantum Arthur-Merlin games. Under described certain assumptions, we show that the exact solution of the subset sum problem my be obtained in polynomial time and the exponential speed-up over the classical algorithms may be possible. We give a numerical example and discuss the complexity of the approach and its further application to the knapsack problem.
We consider the SUBSET SUM problem and its important variants in this paper. In the SUBSET SUM problem, a (multi-)set $X$ of $n$ positive numbers and a target number $t$ are given, and the task is to find a subset of $X$ with the maximal sum that does not exceed $t$. It is well known that this problem is NP-hard and admits fully polynomial-time approximation schemes (FPTASs). In recent years, it has been shown that there does not exist an FPTAS of running time $\tilde\OO( 1/ε^{2-δ})$ for arbitrary small $δ>0$ assuming ($\min$,+)-convolution conjecture~\cite{bringmann2021fine}. However, the low…
The "Subset Sum problem" is a very well-known NP-complete problem. In this work, a top-k variation of the "Subset Sum problem" is considered. This problem has wide application in recommendation systems, where instead of k best objects the k best subsets of objects with the lowest (or highest) overall scores are required. Given an input set R of n real numbers and a positive integer k, our target is to generate the k best subsets of R such that the sum of their elements is minimized. Our solution methodology is based on constructing a metadata structure G for a given n. Each node of G stores a …
Given positive integers $a_1,..., a_n, t$, the fixed weight subset sum problem is to find a subset of the $a_i$ that sum to $t$, where the subset has a prescribed number of elements. It is this problem that underlies the security of modern knapsack cryptosystems, and solving the problem results directly in a message attack. We present new exponential algorithms that do not rely on lattices, and hence will be applicable when lattice basis reduction algorithms fail. These algorithms rely on a generalization of the notion of splitting system given by Stinson. In particular, if the problem has len…
Subset-Sum is an NP-complete problem where one must decide if a multiset of $n$ integers contains a subset whose elements sum to a target value $m$. The best-known classical and quantum algorithms run in time $\tilde{O}(2^{n/2})$ and $\tilde{O}(2^{n/3})$, respectively, based on the well-known meet-in-the-middle technique. Here we introduce a novel classical dynamic-programming-based data structure with applications to Subset-Sum and a number of variants, including Equal-Sums (where one seeks two disjoint subsets with the same sum), 2-Subset-Sum (a relaxed version of Subset-Sum where each item …
The Subset Sum problem asks whether a given set of $n$ positive integers contains a subset of elements that sum up to a given target $t$. It is an outstanding open question whether the $O^*(2^{n/2})$-time algorithm for Subset Sum by Horowitz and Sahni [J. ACM 1974] can be beaten in the worst-case setting by a "truly faster", $O^*(2^{(0.5-δ)n})$-time algorithm, with some constant $δ> 0$. Continuing an earlier work [STACS 2015], we study Subset Sum parameterized by the maximum bin size $β$, defined as the largest number of subsets of the $n$ input integers that yield the same sum. For every $ε> …
The subset sum algorithm is a natural heuristic for the classical Bin Packing problem: In each iteration, the algorithm finds among the unpacked items, a maximum size set of items that fits into a new bin. More than 35 years after its first mention in the literature, establishing the worst-case performance of this heuristic remains, surprisingly, an open problem. Due to their simplicity and intuitive appeal, greedy algorithms are the heuristics of choice of many practitioners. Therefore, better understanding simple greedy heuristics is, in general, an interesting topic in its own right. Very r…
We present an $\mathcal{O}^\star(2^{0.5n})$ time and $\mathcal{O}^\star(2^{0.249999n})$ space randomized algorithm for solving worst-case Subset Sum instances with $n$ integers. This is the first improvement over the long-standing $\mathcal{O}^\star(2^{n/2})$ time and $\mathcal{O}^\star(2^{n/4})$ space algorithm due to Schroeppel and Shamir (FOCS 1979). We breach this gap in two steps: (1) We present a space efficient reduction to the Orthogonal Vectors Problem (OV), one of the most central problem in Fine-Grained Complexity. The reduction is established via an intricate combination of the met…
The subset sum problem is known to be an NP-hard problem in the field of computer science with the fastest known approach having a run-time complexity of $O(2^{0.3113n})$. A modified version of this problem is known as the perfect sum problem and extends the subset sum idea further. This extension results in additional complexity, making it difficult to compute for a large input. In this paper, I propose a probabilistic approach which approximates the solution to the perfect sum problem by approximating the distribution of potential sums. Since this problem is an extension of the subset sum, o…
We present space efficient Monte Carlo algorithms that solve Subset Sum and Knapsack instances with $n$ items using $O^*(2^{0.86n})$ time and polynomial space, where the $O^*(\cdot)$ notation suppresses factors polynomial in the input size. Both algorithms assume random read-only access to random bits. Modulo this mild assumption, this resolves a long-standing open problem in exact algorithms for NP-hard problems. These results can be extended to solve Binary Linear Programming on $n$ variables with few constraints in a similar running time. We also show that for any constant $k\geq 2$, random…
