arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2511.01211econ.GNcs.CEcs.CLcs.DLq-fin.EC
收藏

经济学论文的新颖性与影响

Novelty and Impact of Economics Papers

Department of Computer Science, Northwestern University(计算机科学系,西北大学)

Chaofeng Wu

AI总结:

本文提出将科学新颖性分解为空间(知识独特性)和时间(前沿参与度)两个正交维度的框架,通过大型语言模型量化论文语义位置,发现二者分别预测引用量与颠覆性影响,构建了四类语义邻域原型。

摘要:

我们提出一个框架,不再将科学新颖性视为论文的单一属性,而是将其视为论文在不断演变的知识图景中位置的反映。我们将这一位置分解为两个正交维度:\textit{空间新颖性},衡量论文与其相邻研究的知识独特性;\textit{时间新颖性},捕捉论文对动态研究前沿的参与度。为了将这些概念付诸实践,我们利用大型语言模型开发语义隔离指标,量化论文相对于全文文献的位置。将该框架应用于大型经济学论文语料库后,我们发现一个基本权衡:这两个维度预测的结果存在系统性差异。时间新颖性主要预测引用量,而空间新颖性预测颠覆性影响。这种区分使我们能够构建语义邻域的类型学,识别出四种与不同且可预测的影响特征相关的原型。我们的研究结果表明,新颖性可以被理解为一种多维结构,其不同形式反映了论文的战略位置,对科学进步具有可衡量且根本不同的影响。

英文摘要:

We propose a framework that recasts scientific novelty not as a single attribute of a paper, but as a reflection of its position within the evolving intellectual landscape. We decompose this position into two orthogonal dimensions: \textit{spatial novelty}, which measures a paper's intellectual distinctiveness from its neighbors, and \textit{temporal novelty}, which captures its engagement with a dynamic research frontier. To operationalize these concepts, we leverage Large Language Models to develop semantic isolation metrics that quantify a paper's location relative to the full-text literature. Applying this framework to a large corpus of economics articles, we uncover a fundamental trade-off: these two dimensions predict systematically different outcomes. Temporal novelty primarily predicts citation counts, whereas spatial novelty predicts disruptive impact. This distinction allows us to construct a typology of semantic neighborhoods, identifying four archetypes associated with distinct and predictable impact profiles. Our findings demonstrate that novelty can be understood as a multidimensional construct whose different forms, reflecting a paper's strategic location, have measurable and fundamentally distinct consequences for scientific progress.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑