arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2405.00247econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

劳动力市场中非传统证书的价值

The Value of Non-Traditional Credentials in the Labor Market

Stanford University(斯坦福大学);Northeastern University(东北大学)

Susan Athey, Emil Palikot

AI总结:

本文通过针对80万名无大学学位的在线证书获得者的随机实验发现,鼓励在LinkedIn分享证书的干预能提升6%的新就业率,且对就业能力较弱者效果更显著,证明低成本干预可缓解信息摩擦并有效促进非传统证书持有者就业。

摘要:

没有正式证书的工人比有证书的工人就业率低得多,但信息摩擦在多大程度上导致了这些差异仍不清楚。我们在超过800,000名来自发展中国家且没有大学学位的在线证书获得者中进行了一项随机实验,通过降低摩擦和提醒来鼓励他们在LinkedIn上分享证书。我们研究了整个样本的证书可见性,并追踪了40,000名学习者的就业结果。该干预使新就业增加了6%(1.0个百分点),对于与证书相关的工作,效果更大,为9%(1.2个百分点)。处理效应集中在基准就业能力较弱的学习者中:处于最低三分位的就业者就业增长了12%,而处于最高三分位的就业者影响微乎其微。对干预最敏感的人群从分享中获益最多,依从者的局部平均处理效应为11个百分点。反事实简历评分表明,证书使候选人的感知质量平均提高8.5分(在1到100的量表上),对弱简历的影响为15-20分,但对强简历的影响接近于零。我们的研究结果表明,信息摩擦极大地限制了没有传统证书的工人的就业,而针对证书可见性的最低成本干预措施可以产生与密集培训计划相当的就业收益。

英文摘要:

Workers without formal credentials experience substantially lower employment rates than their credentialed counterparts, but the extent to which information frictions contribute to these disparities remains unclear. We conducted a randomized experiment with over 800,000 online certificate earners from developing countries who lack college degrees, encouraging credential sharing on LinkedIn through reduced friction and reminders. We study credential visibility for the full sample and track employment outcomes for 40,000 learners. The intervention increased new employment by 6% (1.0 percentage point), with larger effects of 9% (1.2 percentage points) for jobs related to certificates. Treatment effects concentrate among learners with weak baseline employability: those in the bottom tercile experience employment gains of 12% while those in the top tercile see negligible effects. Those most responsive to the intervention benefit most from sharing, with a local average treatment effect of 11 percentage points for compliers. Counterfactual resume scoring shows that credentials improve perceived candidate quality by 8.5 points on average (on a scale from 1 to 100), with effects of 15-20 points for weak resumes but near-zero for strong resumes. Our findings demonstrate that information frictions substantially constrain employment for workers without traditional credentials, and that minimal-cost interventions targeting credential visibility can generate employment gains comparable to intensive training programs.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑