arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2606.06702cs.HC
收藏

对抗性协同思考:HCI写作中多种GenAI工具的校准与三角验证

Adversarial Co-Thinking: Calibration and Triangulation Across Multiple GenAI Tools in HCI Writing

Aalto University(阿尔托大学)

Pia Tukkinen

AI总结:

本文探讨在学术论文起草阶段完全嵌入GenAI工具(Claude、ChatGPT、Gemini)的协作写作模式,提出“对抗性协同思考”方法:利用过往同行评审校准工具,并让工具输出相互对抗以测试而非盲从,强调评估能力而非生成能力是关键技能。

摘要:

本文探讨当GenAI工具完全嵌入学术论文起草阶段而非仅限于后期润色时会发生什么。为了研究密集的多工具GenAI工作流程与传统学术写作的差异,我从第一句话开始,同时使用三种GenAI工具——Claude、ChatGPT和Gemini——起草本文,并将其输出与我自己的预期贡献进行比较。在整个过程中,出现了一种反复出现的模式,我称之为“对抗性协同思考”:利用过往同行评审来校准工具,然后让它们的输出相互对抗以进行测试,而非盲从。我认为,从默认赞美工具中挖掘出真正的批评是与这些工具合作的核心实践挑战,而关键技能在于评估而非生成。对抗性协同思考是一种高技能的认知实践:它可以放大已有的专业知识,但也可能掩盖其缺失。我进一步认为,当前的披露框架难以捕捉这种转变。本文为研讨会讨论提供了关于自主性、监督、访问公平性和披露的四项建议。

英文摘要:

This paper examines what happens when GenAI tools are fully embedded in the drafting of an academic paper rather than confined to late-stage polishing. To investigate how an intensive multi-tool GenAI workflow differs from conventional academic writing, I drafted this paper from the first sentence in parallel with three GenAI tools - Claude, ChatGPT, and Gemini - comparing their outputs against my own intended contribution. Across this process, a recurring pattern took shape that I call adversarial co-thinking: using past peer reviews to calibrate the tools, then setting their outputs against one another to be tested rather than deferred to. I argue that surfacing genuine critique from tools that default to praise is a central practical challenge of working with these tools, and that the skill at stake is evaluative rather than generative. Adversarial co-thinking is a high-skill epistemic practice: it can amplify expertise where it exists, but it can also mask its absence. I further argue that current disclosure frameworks are poorly equipped to capture this shift. The paper offers four propositions for workshop discussion concerning autonomy, supervision, equity of access, and disclosure.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑