用领域特定的生成式AI挑衅促进批判性思维
Promoting Critical Thinking With Domain-Specific Generative AI Provocations
AI总结:
本文通过两个生成式AI工具的案例,探讨领域特定的AI挑衅如何通过产生摩擦和用户互动促进批判性思维,强调需超越静态挑衅向适应用户需求的设计转型。
摘要:
关于生成式AI(GenAI)对批判性思维影响的证据混杂,研究表明其潜在危害和益处取决于实施方式。一些人认为,由AI驱动的挑衅,如要求人类澄清和论证的问题,有助于激发批判性思维。基于我们设计和评估两个生成式AI工具(ArtBot用于艺术解读领域,Privy用于AI隐私领域)的经验,我们反思了设计决策如何塑造此类挑衅的形式和有效性。我们的观察和用户反馈表明,通过产生摩擦和依赖用户贡献的互动,领域特定的挑衅可以有意义地支持批判性思维。我们展示了两个原型的用户经历,并讨论了支持批判性思维可能需要超越静态挑衅,转向适应用户偏好和专业知识水平的方案。
英文摘要:
The evidence on the effects of generative AI (GenAI) on critical thinking is mixed, with studies suggesting both potential harms and benefits depending on its implementation. Some argue that AI-driven provocations, such as questions asking for human clarification and justification, are beneficial for eliciting critical thinking. Drawing on our experience designing and evaluating two GenAI-powered tools for knowledge work, ArtBot in the domain of fine art interpretation and Privy in the domain of AI privacy, we reflect on how design decisions shape the form and effectiveness of such provocations. Our observations and user feedback suggest that domain-specific provocations, implemented through productive friction and interactions that depend on user contribution, can meaningfully support critical thinking. We present participant experiences with both prototypes and discuss how supporting critical thinking may require moving beyond static provocations toward approaches that adapt to user preferences and levels of expertise.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。