arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2405.00341cs.HC
收藏

Google 还是 ChatGPT:谁是大学生更好的帮手

Google or ChatGPT: Who is the Better Helper for University Students

Mengmeng Zhang, Xiantong Yang

AI总结:

本研究通过混合方法调查台湾大学生学业求助偏好,发现学生更倾向使用 ChatGPT,并利用随机森林和 LightGBM 识别出 GenAI 流畅度、GenAI 失真和年龄是影响其选择的核心因素,进而提出教育者应培养批判性思维、技术人员应优化聊天与搜索功能整合的建议。

摘要:

利用信息技术工具进行学业求助已成为大学生中的流行趋势。在生成式人工智能(GenAI)与传统搜索引擎的演进过程中,当学生面临学业挑战时,他们更倾向于使用 Google,还是更倾向于使用 ChatGPT?影响学习者偏好使用 ChatGPT 进行学业求助的关键因素有哪些?这些问题值得关注。本研究采用混合方法研究设计,调查台湾大学生的在线学业求助偏好。结果表明,学生倾向于优先使用 ChatGPT 寻求学业帮助,反映出 GenAI 在教育领域的潜在普及趋势。此外,在比较七种机器学习算法时,随机森林和 LightGBM 算法表现出更优的性能。研究采用这两种算法评估了 18 个潜在因素的预测能力,发现 GenAI 流畅度、GenAI 失真和年龄是影响大学生学业求助方式的核心因素。总体而言,本研究强调教育者应优先培养学生的批判性思维能力,技术人员应提升 ChatGPT 和 Google 搜索的流畅性与可靠性,并探索聊天功能与搜索功能的整合,以实现最优平衡。

英文摘要:

Using information technology tools for academic help-seeking among college students has become a popular trend. In the evolutionary process between Generation Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) and traditional search engines, when students face academic challenges, do they tend to prefer Google, or are they more inclined to utilize ChatGPT? And what are the key factors influencing learners' preference to use ChatGPT for academic help-seeking? These relevant questions merit attention. The study employed a mixed-methods research design to investigate Taiwanese university students' online academic help-seeking preferences. The results indicated that students tend to prefer using ChatGPT to seek academic assistance, reflecting the potential popularity of GenAI in the educational field. Additionally, in comparing seven machine learning algorithms, the Random Forest and LightGBM algorithms exhibited superior performance. These two algorithms were employed to evaluate the predictive capability of 18 potential factors. It was found that GenAI fluency, GenAI distortions, and age were the core factors influencing how university students seek academic help. Overall, this study underscores that educators should prioritize the cultivation of students' critical thinking skills, while technical personnel should enhance the fluency and reliability of ChatGPT and Google searches and explore the integration of chat and search functions to achieve optimal balance.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑