arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2111.07765cs.AI
收藏

机器智能不可能的论证

An argument for the impossibility of machine intelligence

University at Buffalo(纽约州立大学布法罗分校)

Jobst Landgrebe, Barry Smith

摘要:

自从名词短语“人工智能”(AI)被创造出来以来,人们一直在争论人类是否能够利用技术创造智能。我们从热力学和数学的角度对这个问题进行了新的阐述。首先,我们定义什么是可以成为AI承载者的代理(设备)。然后,我们表明,由Hutter和其他人提出的,仍然被AI社区接受的“智能”的主流定义太弱了,甚至无法捕捉到当我们将智能归于昆虫时所涉及的内容。然后,我们总结了罗德尼·布鲁克斯提出的基本(节肢动物)智能的非常有用的定义,我们确定了一个人工智能智能体需要具备的属性,以便通过这个定义成为智能的承载者。最后,我们表明,从创建这样一个代理所需的学科的角度来看,即数学和物理学,这些属性既不是通过隐式或显式的数学设计也不是通过建立一个人工智能可以自发进化的环境来实现的。

英文摘要:

Since the noun phrase `artificial intelligence' (AI) was coined, it has been debated whether humans are able to create intelligence using technology. We shed new light on this question from the point of view of themodynamics and mathematics. First, we define what it is to be an agent (device) that could be the bearer of AI. Then we show that the mainstream definitions of `intelligence' proposed by Hutter and others and still accepted by the AI community are too weak even to capture what is involved when we ascribe intelligence to an insect. We then summarise the highly useful definition of basic (arthropod) intelligence proposed by Rodney Brooks, and we identify the properties that an AI agent would need to possess in order to be the bearer of intelligence by this definition. Finally, we show that, from the perspective of the disciplines needed to create such an agent, namely mathematics and physics, these properties are realisable by neither implicit nor explicit mathematical design nor by setting up an environment in which an AI could evolve spontaneously.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑