arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2208.02187cs.AI
收藏

论现象意识与计算智能的独立性

On the independence between phenomenal consciousness and computational intelligence

Universidad Pontificia de Comillas(卡米亚斯大主教大学)

Eduardo C. Garrido Merchán, Sara Lumbreras

摘要:

意识和智力是民间心理学和一般社会通常理解为依赖的属性。人工智能这个术语以及近年来它设法解决的问题,已经被证明是一个论据,证明机器有某种意识。按照罗素的类比,如果一台机器能够做一个有意识的人所做的事情,那么机器有意识的可能性就会增加。然而,这种类比的社会影响是灾难性的。具体地说,如果权利被赋予能够解决神经正常人所能解决的问题的实体,那么机器是否可能比残疾人拥有更多的权利?例如,自闭症综合症谱系可能会使人无法解决机器可以解决的问题。我们认为,答案显然是否定的,因为解决问题并不意味着意识。因此,我们将在本文中讨论现象意识和至少计算智能是如何独立的,以及为什么机器不拥有现象意识,尽管它们可能发展出比人类更高的计算智能。为了做到这一点,我们试图制定一个客观的衡量计算智能的标准,并研究它如何在人类,动物和机器中呈现。类似地,我们研究现象意识作为一个二分变量,以及它是如何分布在人类,动物和机器。由于现象意识和计算智能是独立的,这一事实对我们在本书中分析的社会具有重要意义。

英文摘要:

Consciousness and intelligence are properties commonly understood as dependent by folk psychology and society in general. The term artificial intelligence and the kind of problems that it managed to solve in the recent years has been shown as an argument to establish that machines experience some sort of consciousness. Following the analogy of Russell, if a machine is able to do what a conscious human being does, the likelihood that the machine is conscious increases. However, the social implications of this analogy are catastrophic. Concretely, if rights are given to entities that can solve the kind of problems that a neurotypical person can, does the machine have potentially more rights that a person that has a disability? For example, the autistic syndrome disorder spectrum can make a person unable to solve the kind of problems that a machine solves. We believe that the obvious answer is no, as problem solving does not imply consciousness. Consequently, we will argue in this paper how phenomenal consciousness and, at least, computational intelligence are independent and why machines do not possess phenomenal consciousness, although they can potentially develop a higher computational intelligence that human beings. In order to do so, we try to formulate an objective measure of computational intelligence and study how it presents in human beings, animals and machines. Analogously, we study phenomenal consciousness as a dichotomous variable and how it is distributed in humans, animals and machines. As phenomenal consciousness and computational intelligence are independent, this fact has critical implications for society that we also analyze in this work.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑