arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2602.10222cs.HC
收藏

理解AI辅助批判性思维对人机决策的影响

Understanding the Effects of AI-Assisted Critical Thinking on Human-AI Decision Making

Purdue University(普渡大学)

Harry Yizhou Tian, Hasan Amin, Ming Yin

AI总结:

本文提出AACT框架,通过分析人类决策理由促进批判性思维,提升人机决策质量,减少对AI的依赖。

摘要:

尽管人类-人工智能决策日益普及,但人类-人工智能团队的决策表现往往仍不理想,部分原因是人类自身推理的不足。在本文中,我们探讨设计能够直接分析人类决策理由并鼓励其反思自身决策的AI系统。我们引入了AI辅助批判性思维(AACT)框架,该框架利用领域特定的AI模型对人类决策的反事实分析,帮助决策者识别其决策论证中的潜在缺陷并支持其修正。通过房地产价格预测的案例研究,我们发现AACT在减少对AI的过度依赖方面优于传统AI决策支持,尽管也引发了更高的认知负荷。子组分析显示,AACT对某些决策者,如非常熟悉AI技术的人,尤其有益。我们最后讨论了我们发现的实践意义、AACT的用例和设计选择,以及使用AI促进批判性思维的考虑因素。

英文摘要:

Despite the growing prevalence of human-AI decision making, the human-AI team's decision performance often remains suboptimal, partially due to insufficient examination of humans' own reasoning. In this paper, we explore designing AI systems that directly analyze humans' decision rationales and encourage critical reflection of their own decisions. We introduce the AI-Assisted Critical Thinking (AACT) framework, which leverages a domain-specific AI model's counterfactual analysis of human decision to help decision-makers identify potential flaws in their decision argument and support the correction of them. Through a case study on house price prediction, we find that AACT outperforms traditional AI-based decision-support in reducing over-reliance on AI, though also triggering higher cognitive load. Subgroup analysis reveals AACT can be particularly beneficial for some decision-makers such as those very familiar with AI technologies. We conclude by discussing the practical implications of our findings, use cases and design choices of AACT, and considerations for using AI to facilitate critical thinking.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑