arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2401.07058cs.HCcs.AI
收藏

更多建议是否有帮助?AI辅助决策中第二意见的影响

Does More Advice Help? The Effects of Second Opinions in AI-Assisted Decision Making

Purdue University(普渡大学);Northeastern University(东北大学)

Zhuoran Lu, Dakuo Wang, Ming Yin

AI总结:

本文通过三项随机实验研究AI辅助决策中第二意见的作用,发现同时呈现第二意见可减少过度依赖但增加依赖不足,而由决策者主动征求第二意见则有望在部分情况下减轻过度依赖而不加剧依赖不足。

摘要:

AI在决策中的辅助已变得普遍,但人们对AI的不当依赖往往导致人机协作表现不尽如人意。本文通过三项预先注册的随机人类受试者实验,探讨提供第二意见是否以及如何影响AI辅助决策中决策者的行为与表现。我们发现,如果AI模型的决策建议与第二意见始终同时呈现,决策者会减少对AI的过度依赖,同时增加对AI的依赖不足,无论第二意见是由同伴还是另一个AI模型生成。然而,如果决策者拥有决定何时征求同伴第二意见的控制权,我们发现他们在某些情况下主动征求第二意见有可能减轻对AI的过度依赖,而不会引发依赖不足的增加。最后,我们讨论了研究结果对促进决策中有效人机协作的启示。

英文摘要:

AI assistance in decision-making has become popular, yet people's inappropriate reliance on AI often leads to unsatisfactory human-AI collaboration performance. In this paper, through three pre-registered, randomized human subject experiments, we explore whether and how the provision of {second opinions} may affect decision-makers' behavior and performance in AI-assisted decision-making. We find that if both the AI model's decision recommendation and a second opinion are always presented together, decision-makers reduce their over-reliance on AI while increase their under-reliance on AI, regardless whether the second opinion is generated by a peer or another AI model. However, if decision-makers have the control to decide when to solicit a peer's second opinion, we find that their active solicitations of second opinions have the potential to mitigate over-reliance on AI without inducing increased under-reliance in some cases. We conclude by discussing the implications of our findings for promoting effective human-AI collaborations in decision-making.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑