打破认知惰性:通过认知对齐重新思考人工智能辅助的数据素养
Disrupting Cognitive Passivity: Rethinking AI-Assisted Data Literacy through Cognitive Alignment
AI总结:
本文提出通过认知对齐框架,重新设计人工智能辅助的数据素养,以避免认知惰性,促进主动思考。
摘要:
AI聊天机器人正越来越多地扮演合作者或教师的角色,在分析、可视化和推理数据和领域问题中发挥作用。然而,AI的默认助手模式,其全面且一次性响应可能削弱从业者通过自身思考发展素养的机会,导致认知惰性。本文基于实证研究和理论证据,认为打破认知惰性需要细致的方法:不仅使AI促进反思性思考,还需要更动态和适应性的策略通过认知对齐——一种将用户认知需求与AI交互模式对齐的框架。在该框架中,我们提供了AI交互模式(传递性或反思性)与用户认知需求(接受性或反思性)之间的映射,否则会导致认知惰性或摩擦。我们进一步讨论了数据素养的启示和未来研究的开放问题。
英文摘要:
AI chatbots are increasingly stepping into roles as collaborators or teachers in analyzing, visualizing, and reasoning through data and domain problem. Yet, AI's default assistant mode with its comprehensive and one-off responses may undermine opportunities for practitioners to develop literacy through their own thinking, inducing cognitive passivity. Drawing on evidence from empirical studies and theories, we argue that disrupting cognitive passivity necessitates a nuanced approach: rather than simply making AI promote deliberative thinking, there is a need for more dynamic and adaptive strategy through cognitive alignment -- a framework that characterizes effective human-AI interaction as a function of alignment between users' cognitive demand and AI's interaction mode. In the framework, we provide the mapping between AI's interaction mode (transmissive or deliberative) and users' cognitive demand (receptive or deliberative), otherwise leading to either cognitive passivity or friction. We further discuss implications and offer open questions for future research on data literacy.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。