arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2403.18340cs.GT
收藏

随机社会选择函数的度量失真:C1最大彩票规则与模拟

The Metric Distortion of Randomized Social Choice Functions: C1 Maximal Lottery Rules and Simulations

Fabian Frank, Patrick Lederer

AI总结:

研究成熟随机社会选择函数(RSCF)的度量失真,证明C1最大彩票规则的度量失真为最优的4,通过模拟发现经典RSCF平均失真接近定制RSCF,且公正文化分布下合理RSCF在选民多时期望失真接近2。

摘要:

随机社会选择函数(RSCF)的度量失真量化了在选民对备选方案的成本由度量空间中的距离给出时,其最坏情况下对最优社会成本的近似比。这一概念最近引起了极大关注,因为已提出许多旨在最小化度量失真的RSCF。然而,这类定制投票规则除了低度量失真外几乎没有规范吸引力,因此我们将研究成熟RSCF的度量失真。具体而言,我们首先证明C1最大彩票规则(一类著名的RSCF)的度量失真为4,这在多数主义RSCF类别中是最优的。其次,我们对RSCF的度量失真进行了大量计算机实验,以深入了解其平均情况性能。这些实验基于一个用于计算彩票度量失真的新线性规划,揭示一些经典RSCF的平均度量失真通常仅略差于专为最小化度量失真设计的RSCF。最后,我们还分析研究了公正文化分布下RSCF的期望度量失真,具体证明在该分布下,当选民数量很大时,每个合理的RSCF的期望度量失真接近2。

英文摘要:

The metric distortion of a randomized social choice function (RSCF) quantifies its worst-case approximation ratio to the optimal social cost when the voters' costs for alternatives are given by distances in a metric space. This notion has recently attracted significant attention as numerous RSCFs that aim to minimize the metric distortion have been suggested. Since such tailored voting rules have, however, little normative appeal other than their low metric distortion, we will study the metric distortion of well-established RSCFs. Specifically, we first show that C1 maximal lottery rules, a well-known class of RSCFs, have a metric distortion of $4$, which is optimal within the class of majoritarian RSCFs. Secondly, we conduct extensive computer experiments on the metric distortion of RSCFs to obtain insights into their average-case performance. These computer experiments are based on a new linear program for computing the metric distortion of a lottery and reveal that the average-case metric distortion of some classical RSCFs is often only slightly worse than that of RSCFs tailored to minimize the metric distortion. Finally, we also analytically study the expected metric distortion of RSCFs for the impartial culture distribution. Specifically, we show that, under this distribution, every reasonable RSCF has an expected metric distortion close to $2$ when the number of voters is large.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑