arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1907.05583stat.ME
收藏

贝叶斯因子能“证明”原假设吗?

Can Bayes Factors "Prove" the Null Hypothesis?

Michael Smithson

摘要:

当原假设和备择假设都具有低可能性时,可以获得有利于原假设的大贝叶斯因子(BF),并且存在被忽略的其他假设,这些假设得到数据的更强有力的支持。随着样本量变得越来越大,它变得越来越有可能,一个强大的BF有利于一个点空对传统的贝叶斯模糊的替代品共同出现的BF有利于各种特定的替代品对空。对于任何BF阈值q和样本均值,存在值n,使得大于n的样本量保证尽管将H 0与常规(模糊)备选方案进行比较的BF超过q,但是对于假设μ的某个范围,将H 0与该范围内的μ进行比较的BF落在1/q以下。本文讨论了这一难题发生的条件,并探讨了解决这一难题的方法。

英文摘要:

It is possible to obtain a large Bayes Factor (BF) favoring the null hypothesis when both the null and alternative hypotheses have low likelihoods, and there are other hypotheses being ignored that are much more strongly supported by the data. As sample sizes become large it becomes increasingly probable that a strong BF favouring a point null against a conventional Bayesian vague alternative co-occurs with a BF favouring various specific alternatives against the null. For any BF threshold q and sample mean, there is a value n such that sample sizes larger than n guarantee that although the BF comparing H0 against a conventional (vague) alternative exceeds q, nevertheless for some range of hypothetical μ, a BF comparing H0 against μ in that range falls below 1/q. This paper discusses the conditions under which this conundrum occurs and investigates methods for resolving it.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑