一种新的贝叶斯检验方法
A New Bayesian Test to test for the Intractability-Countering Hypothesis
摘要:
我们提出了一个新的假设检验,其中我们寻求的零条件的数据的概率,其中的零是一个简化进行,以对抗更复杂的模型的棘手性,更简单的零模型嵌套在。由于更复杂的模型变得难以处理,空模型使用简化的假设,该假设允许在给定数据的情况下学习未知参数向量。贝叶斯因子被证明是已知的,只有一个未知的数据依赖常数的比例-一个问题,不能治愈使用处方类似的建议,以解决贝叶斯因子计算引起的问题,由非信息先验。因此,需要一个新的测试,我们可以绕过贝叶斯因子计算。在该测试中,我们从模型中生成数据,其中原假设为真,并且可以通过比较给定测量数据的模型参数的边缘化后验与给定此类生成数据的后验,在测量数据中获得对原假设的支持。然而,这样一个比率的边缘化后验可能混淆解释的比较支持在一个测量的数据为空,在另一个数据集为一个不同的空。给定其中进行这种比较的应用,我们可替代地通过识别与测量数据不太一致的模型参数来定义在测量数据集中对空值的支持,所述模型参数比给定生成的数据的最低可能性低,并且认识到这样的参数值的数量越高,在测量数据中对空值的支持就越少。然后,在基于MCMC的方案内,通过在给定测量数据的情况下,在与测量数据相同或比与生成数据更一致的参数值上对后验进行边缘化,来给出数据上的空条件的概率。
英文摘要:
We present a new test of hypothesis in which we seek the probability of the null conditioned on the data, where the null is a simplification undertaken to counter the intractability of the more complex model, that the simpler null model is nested within. With the more complex model rendered intractable, the null model uses a simplifying assumption that capacitates the learning of an unknown parameter vector given the data. Bayes factors are shown to be known only up to a ratio of unknown data-dependent constants--a problem that cannot be cured using prescriptions similar to those suggested to solve the problem caused to Bayes factor computation, by non-informative priors. Thus, a new test is needed in which we can circumvent Bayes factor computation. In this test, we undertake generation of data from the model in which the null hypothesis is true and can achieve support in the measured data for the null by comparing the marginalised posterior of the model parameter given the measured data, to that given such generated data. However, such a ratio of marginalised posteriors can confound interpretation of comparison of support in one measured data for a null, with that in another data set for a different null. Given an application in which such comparison is undertaken, we alternatively define support in a measured data set for a null by identifying the model parameters that are less consistent with the measured data than is minimally possible given the generated data, and realising that the higher the number of such parameter values, less is the support in the measured data for the null. Then, the probability of the null conditional on the data is given within an MCMC-based scheme, by marginalising the posterior given the measured data, over parameter values that are as, or more consistent with the measured data, than with the generated data.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。