叙事框架:一种分析人工智能伦理与政策 discourse 中隐喻的新方法
Narrative Frames: A New Approach to Analysing Metaphors in AI Ethics and Policy Discourse
AI总结:
本文提出Narrative Frames框架,通过归纳编码和交叉参考,系统分析AI政策 discourse 中隐喻,解决现有方法定义不一致的问题,为研究者和政策制定者提供共同词汇。
摘要:
隐喻深刻影响我们对复杂问题如人工智能的推理方式,但现有政治 discourse 中隐喻分析方法存在定义和方法不一致的问题。本文介绍Narrative Frames,一种新的分类系统,通过归纳编码685个隐喻和交叉参考82项批判性隐喻分析研究,提供标准化框架来识别和分析AI政策辩论中的隐喻。该系统基于Lakoff和Johnson的概念隐喻理论,将类型学建立在实证数据和已确立的理论概念之上,解决定义模糊性问题,以实现跨研究比较。Narrative Frames系统为研究者、记者和政策制定者提供共同词汇,分析隐喻如何塑造公众认知和政策优先事项。通过揭示 discourse 中存在的和缺失的框架,该方法使更透明地分析潜在假设和权力动态。本文讨论局限性并提出未来应用,包括使用大型语言模型进行计算扩展。
英文摘要:
Metaphors fundamentally shape how we reason about complex issues like artificial intelligence, yet current approaches to metaphor analysis in political discourse suffer from inconsistent definitions and methodologies. This paper introduces Narrative Frames, a novel categorisation system that addresses these limitations by providing a standardised framework for identifying and analysing metaphors in AI policy debates. Building on Lakoff and Johnson's conceptual metaphor theory, we derive 49 distinct narrative frames through a two-stage process: inductively coding 685 metaphors from the MetaNet database, then cross-referencing findings with 82 critical metaphor analysis studies. This methodology grounds the typology in both empirical data and established theoretical concepts while resolving definitional ambiguities that have hindered cross-study comparison. The Narrative Frames system offers researchers, journalists, and policymakers a shared vocabulary for analysing how metaphors shape public perception and policy priorities in AI governance. By revealing both the frames present and notably absent in discourse, this approach enables more transparent analysis of underlying assumptions and power dynamics. We discuss limitations and propose future applications, including computational scaling using large language models.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。