arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2601.12152cs.HC
收藏

谁拥有创造力,谁做实际工作?在LLM支持的研究构想中的权衡

Who Owns Creativity and Who Does the Work? Trade-offs in LLM-Supported Research Ideation

School of Information, University of Texas at Austin(德克萨斯大学奥斯汀分校信息学院);Texas Advanced Computing Center(德克萨斯高级计算中心)

Houjiang Liu, Yujin Choi, Sanjana Gautam, Gabriel Jaffe, Soo Young Rieh, Matthew Lease

AI总结:

本文探讨了LLM支持的研究构想中创造力归属与工作分配的权衡,发现人类努力从构想转向验证,所有权成为协商结果,强调研究人员的赋权。

摘要:

基于LLM的智能体提供了加速科学和重塑研究工作的新潜力。然而,研究人员的贡献质量会因人类引导智能体行为的能力而显著变化。我们如何最好地利用这些工具来增强科学创造力,而不损害驱动研究的贡献和所有权方面?为了研究这个问题,我们开发了一个集成三个角色——构想者、撰写者和评估者——的智能研究构想系统,跨越三个控制级别——低、中和高强度。我们的混合方法研究涉及54名研究人员,揭示了LLM智能体如何重塑科学创造力的三个关键发现:1)感知的创造力支持并不随着更大的控制而简单线性增加;2)人类的努力从构想转向验证想法;3)所有权成为人类和AI之间的协商结果。我们的发现表明,LLM智能体的设计应强调研究人员的赋权,培养对强想法的归属感,而不是将研究人员减少为操作自动化AI驱动过程。

英文摘要:

LLM-based agents offer new potential to accelerate science and reshape research work. However, the quality of researcher contributions can vary significantly depending on human ability to steer agent behaviors. How can we best use these tools to augment scientific creativity without undermining aspects of contribution and ownership that drive research? To investigate this, we developed an agentic research ideation system integrating three roles -- Ideator, Writer, and Evaluator -- across three control levels -- Low, Medium, and Intensive. Our mixed-methods study with 54 researchers suggests three key findings in how LLM-based agents reshape scientific creativity: 1) perceived creativity support does not simply increase linearly with greater control; 2) human effort shifts from ideating to verifying ideas; and 3) ownership becomes a negotiated outcome between human and AI. Our findings suggest that LLM agent design should emphasize researcher empowerment, fostering a sense of ownership over strong ideas rather than reducing researchers to operating an automated AI-driven process.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑