The classical variational phase-field model for brittle fracture effectively predicts the growth of large pre-existing cracks. However, the modeling of crack nucleation continues to be a significant challenge. Crack nucleation under uniform stress depends on the material's strength surface whose description is fundamentally incompatible with the energy-based Griffith propagation criterion. To address this, three main phase-field approaches have emerged, each attempting to reconcile material strength and toughness. The first, known as the classical variational approach, preserves the variational structure but fails to accurately incorporate the strength surface. In contrast, the other two approaches -- the complete nucleation and hybrid cohesive zone models -- sacrifice variational consistency. Among these, only the complete nucleation approach precisely accounts for the strength surface. All three approaches, especially the second one, deviate from the sharp variational theory of brittle fracture, raising concerns about their reliability in predicting the growth of cracks under non-mode-I loading. This paper evaluates precisely this issue. It is the first in a series of studies comparing the three approaches, systematically investigating crack growth under mode II, mode III, and mixed-mode loadings. The results confirm that the complete nucleation approach effectively predicts crack growth across all investigated problems, and its predictions agree well with those from other two approaches for tension-dominated cases. Additionally, the findings highlight that inaccurate accounting of the strength surface in the classical variational approach can influence crack path predictions. Lastly, they reveal that modifying the crack driving force to incorporate the strength surface in the hybrid cohesive zone approach causes crack propagation at an incorrect fracture toughness.
Femtosecond laser written patterns at the surface of brittle materials may show a regenerative random transition from self-organized to disordered structures. Here, we show that this random intermittent behaviour carries relevant fracture statistics information, such as the so-called Weibull parameters. Furthermore, we draw a phenomenological analogy with idle and busy periods arising in queueing systems that we used to establish that these successive laser generated cycles are statistically independent. Based on this analogy and together with microscopic observations, we propose an experiment…
The aim of the paper is to propose a paradigm shift for the variational approach of brittle fracture. Both dynamics and the limit case of statics are treated in a same framework. By contrast with the usual incremental approach, we use a space-time principle covering the whole loading and crack evolution. The emphasis is given on the modelling of the crack extension by the internal variable formalism and a dissipation potential as in plasticity, rather than Griffith's original approach based on the surface area. The new formulation appears to be more fruitful for generalization than the standar…
Dual three-dimensional networks of structural and transport elements were combined to model the effect of fracture on mass transport in quasi-brittle geomaterials. Element connectivity of the structural network, representing elasticity and fracture, was defined by the Delaunay tessellation of a random set of points. The connectivity of transport elements within the transport network was defined by the Voronoi tessellation of the same set of points. A new discretisation strategy for domain boundaries was developed to apply boundary conditions for the coupled analyses. The properties of transpor…
Analytical models have been developed for fracture propagation over the last several decades and are now considered with renewed interest; the range of their applicability varies for different materials and different loading conditions. Systematic experimental measurements and numerical simulations are presented against an asymptotic prediction for the crack trajectory developing in solids with small voids (of circular and elliptical shape). The experiments also cover the dynamic regime, where new features involving crack kinking and roughness of the fracture surface occur.
The problem of a crack impinging on an interface has been thoroughly investigated in the last three decades due to its important role in the mechanics and physics of solids. In this investigation, this problem is revisited in view of the recent progresses on the phase field approach to brittle fracture. In this concern, a novel formulation combining the phase field approach for modeling brittle fracture in the bulk and a cohesive zone model for pre-existing adhesive interfaces is herein proposed to investigate the competition between crack penetration and deflection at an interface. The model,…
Dynamic fracture experiments were performed in PMMA over a wide range of velocities and reveal that the fracture energy exhibits an abrupt 3-folds increase from its value at crack initiation at a well-defined critical velocity, below the one associated to the onset of micro-branching instability. This transition is associated with the appearance of conics patterns on fracture surfaces that, in many materials, are the signature of damage spreading through the nucleation and growth of microcracks. A simple model allows to relate both the energetic and fractographic measurements. These results su…
We introduce a lattice model able to describe damage and yielding in heterogeneous materials ranging from brittle to ductile ones. Ductile fracture surfaces, obtained when the system breaks once the strain is completely localized, are shown to correspond to minimum energy surfaces. The similarity of the resulting fracture paths to the limits of brittle fracture or minimum energy surfaces is quantified. The model exhibits a smooth transition from brittleness to ductility. The dynamics of yielding exhibits avalanches with a power-law distribution.
Fracture in aluminum alloys with precipitates involves at least two mechanisms, namely, ductile fracture of the aluminum-rich matrix and brittle fracture of the precipitates. In this work, a coupled crystal plasticity-phase field model for mixed ductile-brittle failure modes is formulated and used to investigate the effect of precipitate morphology and size distribution on damage evolution in aluminum alloys. A thermodynamically consistent framework for elastic and plastic work dissipation in the fracture process zone is used to formulate the coupled constitutive behavior for brittle and ducti…
The fracture behavior of brittle and ductile materials can be strongly influenced by thermal fluctuations, especially in micro- and nano-devices as well as in rubberlike and biological materials. However, temperature effects, in particular on the brittle-to-ductile transition, still require a deeper theoretical investigation. As a step in this direction we propose a theory, based on equilibrium statistical mechanics, able to describe the temperature dependent brittle fracture and brittle-to-ductile transition in prototypical discrete systems consisting in a lattice with breakable elements. Con…
Phase field method has been widely used because of its excellent ability to simulate fracture problems. At present, the implementation process is mainly based on commercial software, and the operation process is relatively complex. In this paper, 2D and 3D phase field models are implemented in the open-source finite element software package AsFem. Compared with commercial software, it is simpler to realize phase field fracture model in AsFem. At the same time, a robust staggered scheme and an efficient monolithic scheme can be used to solve the displacement field and phase field sub-problem, a…
A Mesoscale Model for Interface-Mediated Plasticity: Investigation of Ductile and Brittle Fracture
City University of Hong Kong（香港城市大学）；University of California, Los Angeles（加州大学洛杉矶分校）；The University of Hong Kong（香港大学）；University of Birmingham（伯明翰大学）
Numerous measurements showed that the crack tip opening angle (CTOA) is nearly constant upon stable ductile fracture in Al alloys which widely used in modern transportation industry. The atomic structure of the very tip of a crack front has remained unknown, however. We have carried out a first-principles density functional theory study to reveal the precise alignment of atoms near the crack tip in single-crystalline Al. The calculations demonstrate that the CTOA increases with the opening displacement, thus the observed constant CTOA in millimeter scale is an entirely plastic effect during du…
The influence of shock-wave-loading profile on the failure processes in a brittle material has been investigated. Tungsten heavy alloy (WHA) specimens have been subjected to two shock-wave loading profiles with a similar peak stress of 15.4 GPa but different pulse durations. Contrary to the strong dependence of strength on wave profile observed in ductile metals, for WHA, specimens subjected to different loading profiles exhibited similar spall strength and damage evolution morphology. Post-mortem examination of recovered samples revealed that dynamic failure for both loading profiles is domin…
Ductility and Brittle Fracture of Tungsten by Disconnection Pile-up on Twin Boundaries
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory（劳伦斯利弗莫尔国家实验室）；Los Alamos National Laboratory（洛斯阿拉莫斯国家实验室）；University of California Irvine（加州大学尔湾分校）；University of California Los Angeles（加州大学洛杉矶分校）；Lehigh University（理海大学）；Northwestern University（西北大学）
Extreme localization of damage in conventional brittle materials is the source of a host of undesirable effects. We show how artificially engineered metamaterials with all brittle constituents can be designed to ensure that every breakable sub-element fails independently. The main role in the proposed design is played by high contrast composite sub-structure with zero-stiffness, furnishing nonlocal stress redistribution. The ability to de-localize cracking in such nominally brittle systems is revealed by the fact that their continuum description is dominated by the gradient (bending) rather th…
A theoretical-computational framework is proposed for predicting the failure behavior of two anisotropic brittle materials, namely, single crystal magnesium and boron carbide. Constitutive equations are derived, in both small and large deformations, by using thermodynamics in order to establish a fully coupled and transient twin and crack system. To study the common deformation mechanisms (e.g., twinning and fracture), which can be caused by extreme mechanical loading, a monolithically-solved Ginzburg--Landau-based phase-field theory coupled with the mechanical equilibrium equation is implemen…
High-fidelity fracture mechanics simulations of multiple microcracks interaction via physics-based models quickly become computationally expensive as the number of microcracks increases. This work develops a Graph Neural Network (GNN) based framework to simulate fracture and stress evolution in brittle materials due to multiple microcracks' interaction. The GNN framework is trained on the dataset generated by XFEM-based fracture simulator. Our framework achieves high prediction accuracy on the test set (compared to an XFEM-based fracture simulator) by engineering a sequence of GNN-based predic…
Quantitative understanding of the fracture toughness of metallic glasses, including the associated ductile-to-brittle transitions, is not yet available. Here we use a simple model of plastic deformation in glasses, coupled to an advanced Eulerian level set formulation for solving complex free boundary problems, to calculate the fracture toughness of metallic glasses as a function of the degree of structural relaxation corresponding to different annealing times near the glass temperature. Our main result indicates the existence of an elasto-plastic crack tip instability for sufficiently relaxed…
Recent progress in nanotechnology enables us to utilize the elastic strain engineering, the emerging technology capable of controlling the physio-chemical properties of materials via externally-imposed elastic strains, for hard materials. Because the range of accessible properties by imposing elastic strains are set by materials' elasticity limits, it is of great importance to suppress the occurrence of any inelastic deformations and failure, and thereby the fundamental knowledge on fracture behavior at nanoscale is highly required. The conventional Weibull theory, which has been widely used f…
The fracture properties of as-cast TiVNbTa, a refractory high-entropy alloy (RHEA), were investigated using four-point bending tests from -139C to 20C under a strain-rate of 10-3 s-1. From those tests and fractography, the conditional fracture toughness values and the brittle-to-ductile transition temperature were obtained. The brittle-to-ductile transition temperature was between -47C to -27C, which gives an estimated activation energy value of 0.52+-0.09 eV for the alloy. This study provides a preliminary understanding of the nature of dislocation motion in a relatively ductile RHEA.
The strength of quasi-brittle materials depends on the ensemble of defects inside the sample and on the way damage accumulates before failure. Using large scale numerical simulations of the random fuse model, we investigate the evolution of the microcrack distribution that is directly related to the strength distribution and its size effects. We show that the broadening of the distribution tail originates from the dominating microcracks in each sample and is related to a tendency of crack coalescence that increases with system size. We study how the observed behavior depends on the disorder pr…
The two-dimensional oscillatory crack instability, experimentally observed in a class of brittle materials under strongly dynamic conditions, has been recently reproduced by a nonlinear phase-field fracture theory. Here we highlight the universal character of this instability by showing that it is present in materials exhibiting widely different near crack tip elastic nonlinearity, and by demonstrating that the oscillations wavelength follows a universal master curve in terms of dissipation-related and nonlinear elastic intrinsic length scales. Moreover, we show that upon increasing the drivin…
Bridging perturbation and variational approaches in brittle fracture
Navier, Ecole des Ponts, Univ Gustave Eiffel, CNRS（纳维尔实验室，巴黎国立桥梁学院，古斯塔夫·埃菲尔大学，法国国家科学研究中心）；Computational Mechanics of Building Materials, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zürich（建筑材料研究所，苏黎世联邦理工学院）；Department of Microsystems Engineering (IMTEK), University of Freiburg（弗莱堡大学微系统工程系）
Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics (LEFM) provides a consistent framework to evaluate quantitatively the energy flux released to the tip of a growing crack. Still, the way in which the crack selects its velocity in response to this energy flux remains far from completely understood. To uncover the underlying mechanisms, we experimentally studied damage and dissipation processes that develop during the dynamic failure of polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA), classically considered as the archetype of brittle amorphous materials. We evidenced a well-defined critical velocity along which failure switches…
This work presents a critical overview of the effects of different aspects of model formulation on crack path selection in quasi-static phase field fracture. We consider different evolution methods, mechanics formulations, fracture dissipation energy formulations, and forms of the irreversibility condition. The different model variants are implemented with common numerical methods based on staggered solution of the phase-field and mechanics sub-problems via FFT-based solvers. These methods mix standard approaches with novel elements, such as the use of bound-constrained conjugate gradients for…
In a recent contribution, Kumar, Bourdin, Francfort, and Lopez-Pamies (J. Mech. Phys. Solids 142:104027, 2020) have introduced a comprehensive macroscopic phase-field theory for the nucleation and propagation of fracture in linear elastic brittle materials under arbitrary quasistatic loading conditions. The theory can be viewed as a natural generalization of the phase-field approximation of the variational theory of brittle fracture of Francfort and Marigo (J. Mech. Phys. Solids 46:1319--1342, 1998) to account for the material strength at large. This is accomplished by the addition of an exter…
We study a planar thin brittle beam subject to elastic deformations and cracks described in terms of a nonlinear Griffith energy functional acting on $SBV$ deformations of the beam. In particular we consider the case in which elastic bulk contributions due to finite bending of the beam are comparable to the surface energy which is necessary to completely break the beam into several large pieces. In the limit of vanishing aspect ratio we rigorously derive an effective Griffith-Euler-Bernoulli functional which acts on piecewise $W^{2,2}$ regular curves representing the midline of the beam. The e…
We develop a numerical methodology for the calculation of mode-I R-curves of brittle and elastoplastic lattice materials, and unveil the impact of lattice topology, relative density and constituent material behavior on the toughening response of 2D isotropic lattices. The approach is based on finite element calculations of the J-integral on a single-edge-notch-bend (SENB) specimen, with individual bars modeled as beams having a linear elastic or a power-law elasto-plastic constitutive behavior and a maximum strain-based damage model. Results for three 2D isotropic lattice topologies (triangula…
Quasi-brittle behavior where macroscopic failure is preceded by stable damaging and intensive cracking activity is a desired feature of materials because it makes fracture predictable. Based on a fiber bundle model with global load sharing we show that blending strength and stiffness disorder of material elements leads to the stabilization of fracture, i.e. samples which are brittle when one source of disorder is present, become quasi-brittle as a consequence of blending. We derive a condition of quasi-brittle behavior in terms of the joint distribution of the two sources of disorder. Breaking…
In this review article we consider the crack growth resistance ofmicrometer and submicrometer sized samples from the fracture mechanics point of view. Standard fracture mechanics test procedures were developed for macroscale samples, and reduction of the specimen dimensions by three to five orders of magnitude has severe consequences. This concerns the interpretation of results obtained by micro and nanomechanics, as well as the life time and failure prediction of micro and nano devices. We discuss the relevant fracture mechanics length scales and their relation to the material specific struct…
A continuum model of fracture that describes, in principle, the propagation and interaction of arbitrary distributions of cracks and voids with evolving topology without a fracture criterion is developed. It involves a 'law of motion' for crack-tips, primarily as a kinematical consequence coupled with thermodynamics. Fundamental kinematics endows the crack-tip with a topological charge. This allows the association of a kinematical conservation law for the charge, resulting in a fundamental evolution equation for the crack-tip field, and in turn the crack field. The vectorial crack field degrad…
