arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2110.09871stat.ME
收藏

贝叶斯因子只能量化证据w.r.t.参数集,而不是w.r.t.参数的(先验)分布

Bayes Factors can only Quantify Evidence w.r.t. Sets of Parameters, not w.r.t. (Prior) Distributions on the Parameter

Patrick Schwaferts, Thomas Augustin

摘要:

贝叶斯因子的特点是既有贝叶斯统计强大的数学框架,又有作为证据量化的有用解释。前者需要一个参数分布,通过看到数据而改变,后者需要两个固定的假设w.r.t.证据量化所指的是什么。当然,这些固定的假设不应该因为看到数据而改变,只有他们的可信度应该改变!然而,正是这样的假设本身的变化(不仅仅是他们的可信度),发生在看到数据,如果他们的内容是由参数分布(最近的趋势,在贝叶斯因子的背景下,大约十年),呈现正确的解释贝叶斯因子,而不是无用的。相反,本文认为,贝叶斯因素的推理基础只能保持,如果假设是一组参数,而不是参数分布。此外,特别注意提供一个明确的术语的背景下的贝叶斯因素的统计推断的大画面,以及知识之间的区别(正式的先验分布,并允许改变)和理论立场(正式的假设,并要求保持固定)的现象。

英文摘要:

Bayes factors are characterized by both the powerful mathematical framework of Bayesian statistics and the useful interpretation as evidence quantification. Former requires a parameter distribution that changes by seeing the data, latter requires two fixed hypotheses w.r.t. which the evidence quantification refers to. Naturally, these fixed hypotheses must not change by seeing the data, only their credibility should! Yet, it is exactly such a change of the hypotheses themselves (not only their credibility) that occurs by seeing the data, if their content is represented by parameter distributions (a recent trend in the context of Bayes factors for about one decade), rendering a correct interpretation of the Bayes factor rather useless. Instead, this paper argues that the inferential foundation of Bayes factors can only be maintained, if hypotheses are sets of parameters, not parameter distributions. In addition, particular attention has been paid to providing an explicit terminology of the big picture of statistical inference in the context of Bayes factors as well as to the distinction between knowledge (formalized by the prior distribution and being allowed to change) and theoretical positions (formalized as hypotheses and required to stay fixed) of the phenomenon of interest.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑