arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2101.03455cs.GT
收藏

概率环境下的近似防策略竞赛规则

Approximately Strategyproof Tournament Rules in the Probabilistic Setting

Kimberly Ding, S. Matthew Weinberg

摘要:

我们考虑的可操作性的比赛规则映射的结果$\binom{n}{2}$成对匹配,并选择一个赢家。先前的工作设计了简单的锦标赛规则,使得没有一对球队可以操纵他们比赛的结果以提高他们获胜的概率超过$1/3$,并且这是任何孔多塞一致的锦标赛规则中最好的可能性(只要存在一个不败的球队,就选择一个不败的球队)[Schneider等人,2017年,Schvartzman等人,2020年]。这些下限要求操纵者精确地知道所有未来匹配的结果。我们采取超越最坏情况的观点,而是考虑“接近均匀”的锦标赛:所有比赛的结果是独立的,没有一支球队被认为赢得任何比赛的概率超过$1/2+\varepsilon$。我们证明了随机单消除法[Schneider et al.,2017年]和一个新的锦标赛规则,我们称之为随机死亡比赛有这样的属性,即没有一对球队可以操纵他们的比赛结果,以提高他们获胜的概率超过$\varepsilon/3 + 2\varepsilon^2/3$,对于所有$\varepsilon$,这是任何孔多塞一致的锦标赛规则中最好的。我们的主要技术贡献是一个递归的框架来分析某些形式的比赛规则的可操作性。除了我们的主要结果,这个观点有助于简化以前的分析随机单消除随机,可能是独立的利益。

英文摘要:

We consider the manipulability of tournament rules which map the results of $\binom{n}{2}$ pairwise matches and select a winner. Prior work designs simple tournament rules such that no pair of teams can manipulate the outcome of their match to improve their probability of winning by more than $1/3$, and this is the best possible among any Condorcet-consistent tournament rule (which selects an undefeated team whenever one exists) [Schneider et al., 2017, Schvartzman et al., 2020]. These lower bounds require the manipulators to know precisely the outcome of all future matches. We take a beyond worst-case view and instead consider tournaments which are "close to uniform": the outcome of all matches are independent, and no team is believed to win any match with probability exceeding $1/2+\varepsilon$. We show that Randomized Single Elimination Bracket [Schneider et al., 2017] and a new tournament rule we term Randomized Death Match have the property that no pair of teams can manipulate the outcome of their match to improve their probability of winning by more than $\varepsilon/3 + 2\varepsilon^2/3$, for all $\varepsilon$, and this is the best possible among any Condorcet-consistent tournament rule. Our main technical contribution is a recursive framework to analyze the manipulability of certain forms of tournament rules. In addition to our main results, this view helps streamline previous analysis of Randomized Single Elimination Bracket, and may be of independent interest.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑