arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1902.01333cs.DLstat.AP
收藏

开放获取大型期刊的使用与引文关系

The relationship between usage and citations in an open access mega journal

Barbara McGillivray, Mathias Astell

摘要:

一篇文章的使用水平、使用时间范围和主题领域与它所累积的引用数量有什么关系?本文旨在通过对多学科、开放获取大型期刊《科学报告》的使用和引文数据进行观察性研究来回答这个问题。这项观察性研究使用以下方法回答了这些问题:最多阅读和最高引用文章的重叠分析;斯皮尔曼相关性测试两年多的总引用计数和不同时间段的使用情况;最多阅读和所有文章的第一个月引用的比较;对早期引用文章的总引用分布和所有其他文章的总引用分布进行Wilcoxon检验。所有分析均使用程序设计语言R进行。由于《科学报告》是一本涵盖所有自然和临床科学的多学科期刊,我们还研究了不同学科之间的差异。我们发现第一年的使用量与发表后前两年的引用量之间存在中度相关性,并且在前6个月内使用量高的文章更有可能更早地首次引用(Wilcoxon=1811500,p < 0.0001),这也与前两年的引用量较高有关(Wilcoxon=8071200,p < 0.0001)。由于这一最后论断是根据本文件其他内容的结果推断出来的,因此需要进一步分析。此外,我们选择的2年分析窗口没有考虑文章的引用半衰期,以及我们使用的科学报告(与大多数学术期刊相比,这是一种非典型的期刊)作为分析文章的来源可能在我们的研究结果中发挥了作用,因此,分析更长的时间框架和对不同的期刊(或期刊组)进行类似的分析可能会导致不同的结论。

英文摘要:

How do the level of usage of an article, the timeframe of its usage and its subject area relate to the number of citations it accrues? This paper aims to answer this question through an observational study of usage and citation data collected about the multidisciplinary, open access mega-journal Scientific Reports. This observational study answers these questions using the following methods: an overlap analysis of most read and top-cited articles; Spearman correlation tests between total citation counts over two years and usage over various timeframes; a comparison of first months of citation for most read and all articles; a Wilcoxon test on the distribution of total citations of early cited articles and the distribution of total citations of all other articles. All analyses were performed using the programming language R. As Scientific Reports is a multidisciplinary journal covering all natural and clinical sciences, we also looked at the differences across subjects. We found a moderate correlation between usage in the first year and citations in the first two years since publication, and that articles with high usage in the first 6 months are more likely to have their first citation earlier (Wilcoxon=1811500, p < 0.0001), which is also related to higher citations in the first two years (Wilcoxon=8071200, p < 0.0001). As this final assertion is inferred based on the results of the other elements of this paper, it requires further analysis. Moreover, our choice of a 2 year window for our analysis did not consider the articles' citation half-life, and our use of Scientific Reports (a journal that is atypical compared to most academic journals) as the source of the articles analysed has likely played a role in our findings, and so analysing a longer timeframe and carrying out similar analysis on a different journal (or group of journals) may lead to different conclusions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑