Journal Impact Factor is a popular metric for determining the quality of a journal in academia. The number of citations received by a journal is a crucial factor in determining the impact factor, which may be misused in multiple ways. Therefore, it is crucial to detect citation anomalies for further identifying manipulation and inflation of impact factor. Citation network models the citation relationship between journals in terms of a directed graph. Detecting anomalies in the citation network is a challenging task which has several applications in spotting citation cartels and citation stack and understanding the intentions behind the citations. In this paper, we present a novel approach to detect the anomalies in a journal-level scientific citation network, and compare the results with the existing graph anomaly detection algorithms. Due to the lack of proper ground-truth, we introduce a journal-level citation anomaly dataset which consists of synthetically injected citation anomalies and use it to evaluate our methodology. Our method is able to predict the anomalous citation pairs with a precision of 100\% and an F1-score of 86%. We further categorize the detected anomalies into various types and reason out possible causes. We also analyze our model on the Microsoft Academic Search dataset - a real-world citation dataset and interpret our results using a case study, wherein our results resemble the citations and SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) rating-change charts, thus indicating the usefulness of our method. We further design `Journal Citation Analysis Tool', an interactive web portal which, given the citation network as an input, shows the journal-level anomalous citation patterns and helps users analyze citation patterns of a given journal over the years.
Publication boost in Web of Science journals and its effect on citation distributions
在本文中,我们表明,在Web of Science数据库中索引的研究文章的数量急剧增加,影响了这些文章中常见的引文分布。首先,我们证明了近年来物理学论文数量的增长是由于现有期刊发表了越来越多的论文,而不是像计算机科学那样出现了更多的新期刊。第二,即使来自较新论文的参考文献通常覆盖较长的时间跨度,如果不纠正不均匀的论文增长,较新的论文被引用的频率高于较旧的论文。然而,尽管引文的分布发生了变化,科学家的引文行为似乎并没有改变。
Systemic Gendered Citation Imbalance in Computer Science: Evidence from Conferences and Journals
Tokyo Metropolitan University(东京都立大学);The University of Osaka(大阪大学);Nara Institute of Science and Technology(奈良先端科学技术大学院大学);Eindhoven University of Technology(埃因霍温理工大学)