arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2511.03378cs.SIcs.CL
收藏

超越引文:测量从研究到新闻与决策制定的思想层面知识扩散

Beyond Citations: Measuring Idea-level Knowledge Diffusion from Research to Journalism and Policy-making

Weizenbaum Institute(韦岑鲍姆研究所);Institute for Media and Communication Studies(媒体与传播研究学院);Technische Universität Berlin(柏林技术大学)

Yangliu Fan, Kilian Buehling, Volker Stocker

AI总结:

本研究提出基于文本的思想层面测量方法,利用72,703篇文献分析媒介效果理论从研究向新闻与决策领域的扩散,揭示不同思想的差异化扩散模式、角色转变及语义趋同特征,拓展了超越引文的知识扩散测量。

摘要:

尽管社会科学知识对各类利益相关者具有重要意义,但测量其向不同领域的扩散仍然是一项挑战。本研究采用一种新颖的基于文本的方法,测量社会科学知识从研究领域向新闻领域和决策制定领域的思想层面扩散。通过这一方法,我们将知识扩散的检测扩展到直接引用测量之外。本研究聚焦于传播科学领域中的关键研究思想——媒介效果理论。利用来自三个领域(即研究、新闻和决策制定)提及这些思想的72,703篇文献(2000-2019年),我们统计了每个领域中这些思想的提及次数,估计了它们特定领域的语境,并追踪和比较了跨领域及随时间变化的差异。总体而言,我们发现不同思想之间的扩散模式和动态变化差异显著,一些思想在其他领域之间扩散,而另一些则没有。基于嵌入回归方法,我们比较了跨领域的语境化含义,发现研究与决策制定之间的距离通常大于研究与新闻之间的距离。我们还发现,思想在跨领域中很大程度上发生了角色转变——从研究中的理论本身,到新闻中的意义建构,再到决策制定中的应用性、行政性使用。随时间推移,我们观察到语义趋同主要发生在实践导向的思想上。我们的结果刻画了社会科学知识在思想层面的跨领域扩散模式和动态,并讨论了超越引文测量知识扩散的意义。

英文摘要:

Despite the importance of social science knowledge for various stakeholders, measuring its diffusion into different domains remains a challenge. This study uses a novel text-based approach to measure the idea-level diffusion of social science knowledge from the research domain to the journalism and policy-making domains. By doing so, we expand the detection of knowledge diffusion beyond the measurements of direct references. Our study focuses on media effects theories as key research ideas in the field of communication science. Using 72,703 documents (2000-2019) from three domains (i.e., research, journalism, and policy-making) that mention these ideas, we count the mentions of these ideas in each domain, estimate their domain-specific contexts, and track and compare differences across domains and over time. Overall, we find that diffusion patterns and dynamics vary considerably between ideas, with some ideas diffusing between other domains, while others do not. Based on the embedding regression approach, we compare contextualized meanings across domains and find that the distances between research and policy are typically larger than between research and journalism. We also find that ideas largely shift roles across domains - from being the theories themselves in research to sense-making in news to applied, administrative use in policy. Over time, we observe semantic convergence mainly for ideas that are practically oriented. Our results characterize the cross-domain diffusion patterns and dynamics of social science knowledge at the idea level, and we discuss the implications for measuring knowledge diffusion beyond citations.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑