arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1802.06807cs.SIcs.CYstat.ML
收藏

论意见和网上讨论的复杂性

On the Complexity of Opinions and Online Discussions

Utkarsh Upadhyay, Abir De, Aasish Pappu, Manuel Gomez-Rodriguez

摘要:

在一个日益两极分化的世界里,那些将复杂性简化为基于情感的简单论点的煽动者越来越受欢迎。意见和在线讨论是否陷入煽动?在这项工作中,我们的目标是提供计算工具来调查这个问题,并通过这样做,探索在线讨论的性质和复杂性及其意见空间,揭示每个参与者的所在。更具体地说,我们提出了一个建模框架,以构建潜在的意见表示在网上讨论,这是一致的人的判断,通过在线投票。如果两种意见在由此产生的潜在意见空间中很接近,那是因为人类认为它们是相似的。我们的建模框架在理论上是有根据的,并在意见和投票模型与矩阵的符号秩之间建立了令人惊讶的联系。此外,它还提供了一套实用的算法来估计潜在的意见空间的维度,并推断在该空间中的在线讨论的参与者所表达的意见在于。在Yahoo!的大型数据集上进行实验。新闻,雅虎!财经,雅虎!体育和新闻编辑室应用程序表明,一维意见模型通常无法准确地表示在线讨论,提供对人类判断和意见的见解,并表明我们的框架能够通过依赖人类判断而不是文本分析来规避语言细微差别,如讽刺或幽默。

英文摘要:

In an increasingly polarized world, demagogues who reduce complexity down to simple arguments based on emotion are gaining in popularity. Are opinions and online discussions falling into demagoguery? In this work, we aim to provide computational tools to investigate this question and, by doing so, explore the nature and complexity of online discussions and their space of opinions, uncovering where each participant lies. More specifically, we present a modeling framework to construct latent representations of opinions in online discussions which are consistent with human judgements, as measured by online voting. If two opinions are close in the resulting latent space of opinions, it is because humans think they are similar. Our modeling framework is theoretically grounded and establishes a surprising connection between opinions and voting models and the sign-rank of a matrix. Moreover, it also provides a set of practical algorithms to both estimate the dimension of the latent space of opinions and infer where opinions expressed by the participants of an online discussion lie in this space. Experiments on a large dataset from Yahoo! News, Yahoo! Finance, Yahoo! Sports, and the Newsroom app suggest that unidimensional opinion models may often be unable to accurately represent online discussions, provide insights into human judgements and opinions, and show that our framework is able to circumvent language nuances such as sarcasm or humor by relying on human judgements instead of textual analysis.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑