arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1701.08008cs.DL
收藏

植根于科学原理的科学评价的新过程和度量标准-版本1

Novel processes and metrics for a scientific evaluation rooted in the principles of science - Version 1

Michaël Bon, Michael Taylor, Gary S. McDowell

摘要:

科学评价是科学家、机构和资助者行为的决定因素,因此是科学发展的关键因素。在这篇文章中,我们提出了一种替代目前的规范评估研究与期刊排名。遵循科学价值的明确定义,我们引入了定性过程,这些过程也可以量化,并产生有意义和易于使用的文章级指标。在我们的方法中,科学家的目标从通过垂直过程说服编辑委员会转变为通过水平过程说服同行。我们认为,这样的评价体系自然提供了不断促进科学质量,可重复性,开放性和合作所需的激励和逻辑。该系统在法律上和技术上都是可行的,可以逐渐导致学术界及其机构对科学过程的自组织重新利用。我们提出了一个实施我们的评价系统的平台“科学的自我期刊”(www.sjscience.org)。

英文摘要:

Scientific evaluation is a determinant of how scientists, institutions and funders behave, and as such is a key element in the making of science. In this article, we propose an alternative to the current norm of evaluating research with journal rank. Following a well-defined notion of scientific value, we introduce qualitative processes that can also be quantified and give rise to meaningful and easy-to-use article-level metrics. In our approach, the goal of a scientist is transformed from convincing an editorial board through a vertical process to convincing peers through an horizontal one. We argue that such an evaluation system naturally provides the incentives and logic needed to constantly promote quality, reproducibility, openness and collaboration in science. The system is legally and technically feasible and can gradually lead to the self-organized reappropriation of the scientific process by the scholarly community and its institutions. We propose an implementation of our evaluation system with the platform "the Self-Journals of Science" (www.sjscience.org).

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑