arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2105.00152cs.DLcs.SIphysics.soc-ph
收藏

科学作为公共产品:科学的公共使用和资助

Science as a Public Good: Public Use and Funding of Science

Yian Yin, Yuxiao Dong, Kuansan Wang, Dashun Wang, Benjamin F. Jones

摘要:

了解科学在公共领域的消费方式对于更深入地理解科学在人类社会中的作用至关重要。虽然科学得到了公共资金的大力支持,但普遍的看法认为,科学研究仍然是一种孤立的或“象牙塔”的活动,与公共用途的联系很弱,研究质量与公共用途之间的关系很小,科学资助与公共用途之间的对应关系也很小。本文介绍了一个测量框架,以检查科学的公共利益的特点,使我们能够研究科学的公共用途,科学的公共资金,以及如何使用和资金的关系。具体来说,我们整合了五个大规模的数据集,这些数据集将所有科学领域的科学出版物与其上游资金支持和下游公共用途联系起来,这些数据集跨越三个公共领域-政府文件,新闻媒体和市场发明。我们发现,科学的公共用途是非常多样化的,不同的公共领域绘制不同的科学领域。然而,在这些差异中,我们发现科学与社会之间的界面存在着关键的对齐形式。首先,尽管人们担心公众不参与高质量的科学,但我们发现,在每个科学领域和公共领域,公众消费的东西和科学中具有高度影响力的东西之间存在普遍的一致性。其次,尽管有无数因素支撑着科学的公共资金,但由此产生的跨领域分配与该领域的集体公共使用惊人地一致。总体而言,科学的公共使用呈现出丰富的专业消费景观,但科学与社会的共同界面在科学使用、公共使用和资金之间具有显著的、可量化的一致性。

英文摘要:

Knowledge of how science is consumed in public domains is essential for a deeper understanding of the role of science in human society. While science is heavily supported by public funding, common depictions suggest that scientific research remains an isolated or 'ivory tower' activity, with weak connectivity to public use, little relationship between the quality of research and its public use, and little correspondence between the funding of science and its public use. This paper introduces a measurement framework to examine public good features of science, allowing us to study public uses of science, the public funding of science, and how use and funding relate. Specifically, we integrate five large-scale datasets that link scientific publications from all scientific fields to their upstream funding support and downstream public uses across three public domains - government documents, the news media, and marketplace invention. We find that the public uses of science are extremely diverse, with different public domains drawing distinctively across scientific fields. Yet amidst these differences, we find key forms of alignment in the interface between science and society. First, despite concerns that the public does not engage high-quality science, we find universal alignment, in each scientific field and public domain, between what the public consumes and what is highly impactful within science. Second, despite myriad factors underpinning the public funding of science, the resulting allocation across fields presents a striking alignment with the field's collective public use. Overall, public uses of science present a rich landscape of specialized consumption, yet collectively science and society interface with remarkable, quantifiable alignment between scientific use, public use, and funding.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑