Web of Science:今天展示了一个错误,可以误导科学研究输出的预测
Web of Science: showing a bug today that can mislead scientific research output's prediction
摘要:
正如它发生在人类活动的各个领域一样,经济问题和从事科学研究的人员的增加改变了科学成果的评估方式以及进行评估的目标。2005年,J. E。赫希指数作为一种不仅能从数量上而且能从质量上衡量个人科学产出的指标,已在世界范围内得到推广。在2007年,美国好施集团建议采用它作为预测未来科学成就的最佳方法,因此,它是研究投资和机构雇用科学人员的有用指南。从那时起,几位作者也一直在使用汤姆森ISI的Web of Science数据库来开发他们的研究成果评估建议。在这里,使用我们开发的软件,我们分析了超过10万篇文章,并表明Web of Science中的一个微妙的缺陷可以夸大收集信息的结果,从而损害了准确性,因此,赫希的建议及其变体的有效性。
英文摘要:
As it happened in all domains of human activities, economic issues and the increase of people working in scientific research have altered the way scientific production is evaluated so as the objectives of performing the evaluation. Introduced in 2005 by J. E. Hirsch as an indicator able to measure individual scientific output not only in terms of quantity, but also in terms of quality, h index has spread throughout the world. In 2007, Hirsch proposed its adoption also as the best to predict future scientific achievement and, consequently, a useful guide for investments in research and for institutions when hiring members for their scientific staff. Since then, several authors have also been using the Thomson ISI Web of Science database to develop their proposals for evaluating research output. Here, using a software we have developed, we analyse more than 100 thousand articles and show that a subtle flaw in Web of Science can inflate the results of info collected, therefore compromising the exactness and, consequently, the effectiveness of Hirsch's proposal and its variations.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。