arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1611.01006cs.MAcs.SIcs.SYeess.SYmath.STstat.APstat.TH
收藏

基于贝叶斯方法的群体决策启发式模型

Bayesian Heuristics for Group Decisions

Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)(麻省理工学院)

M. Amin Rahimian, Ali Jadbabaie

AI总结:

本文提出了一种基于贝叶斯规则的群体决策启发式模型,分析了信息结构和概率分布对群体决策效率的影响,揭示了重复互动导致的过度自信和极端选择倾向。

摘要:

我们提出了一种推理和群体启发式决策模型,该模型基于贝叶斯规则,但避免了部分观测环境下不完整信息的理性推断复杂性,这在群体互动中是典型的特征。我们的模型也符合双过程心理理论:群体成员在相互互动初期行为理性(慢而审慎的模式);在随后的决策阶段,他们依赖于复制第一阶段经验的启发式方法(快而自动的模式)。我们专门将此模型应用于一个群体决策场景,其中私人观察在开始时接收,而代理人旨在根据所有群体成员的总体观察采取最佳行动。我们研究了信息结构和决定概率分布的属性,这些属性决定了所谓的“贝叶斯启发式”结构,即模型中代理遵循的结构。我们还分析了两类线性行动更新和对数线性信念更新的群体决策结果,并展示了由于个体之间的重复互动导致的许多低效现象,导致过度自信的信念以及向极端选择的转变。然而,平衡的常规结构在聚合个体初始信息方面表现出一定的效率。这些结果不仅验证了关于群体决策的一些已知见解,还通过揭示群体衰减过程的额外机理解释以及关于群体互动模型的心理和认知直觉来补充这些见解。

英文摘要:

We propose a model of inference and heuristic decision-making in groups that is rooted in the Bayes rule but avoids the complexities of rational inference in partially observed environments with incomplete information, which are characteristic of group interactions. Our model is also consistent with a dual-process psychological theory of thinking: the group members behave rationally at the initiation of their interactions with each other (the slow and deliberative mode); however, in the ensuing decision epochs, they rely on a heuristic that replicates their experiences from the first stage (the fast automatic mode). We specialize this model to a group decision scenario where private observations are received at the beginning, and agents aim to take the best action given the aggregate observations of all group members. We study the implications of the information structure together with the properties of the probability distributions which determine the structure of the so-called "Bayesian heuristics" that the agents follow in our model. We also analyze the group decision outcomes in two classes of linear action updates and log-linear belief updates and show that many inefficiencies arise in group decisions as a result of repeated interactions between individuals, leading to overconfident beliefs as well as choice-shifts toward extremes. Nevertheless, balanced regular structures demonstrate a measure of efficiency in terms of aggregating the initial information of individuals. These results not only verify some well-known insights about group decision-making but also complement these insights by revealing additional mechanistic interpretations for the group declension-process, as well as psychological and cognitive intuitions about the group interaction model.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑