arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1506.05375physics.soc-phcs.DLnlin.AO
收藏

同行评审期刊和论文集出版物中共同作者影响力的一致性测量

Coherent measures of the impact of co-authors in peer review journals and in proceedings publications

Marcel Ausloos

摘要:

本文主要讨论不同类型出版物中的合著者效应,在衡量研究影响力时,合著者效应通常没有得到同等的重视。{ \it先验}在主要研究者(LI)的总合著者核心价值$m_a$与其在同行评审期刊($j$)或论文集($p$)中发表的相关价值之间发现了非预期的关系。发现了令人惊讶的线性关系:$ m_a^{(j)} + 0.4\;m_a^{(p)} = m_a^{(jp)} $。此外,另一种关系被发现有关的总引文数,$A_a$,即表面的引用大小排名直方图高达$m_a$的措施。存在另一种线性关系:$A_a^{(j)} + 1.36\; A_a^{(p)} = A_a^{(jp)} $。这些实证研究结果系数(0.4和1.36)的支持,根据经验幂律之间的作者的联合出版物的数量和排名的合著者的考虑。此外,一个简单的幂律关系之间的$m_a$和数量($r_M$)的共同作者的LI:$m_a\simeq r_M^μ$ ;幂律指数$μ$取决于类型($j$或$p$)的出版物。这些简单的关系,在这个时候仅限于物理学出版物,意味着共同作者是一个“更积极的措施”的主要研究者的作用,在这两种类型的科学产出,比赫希指数可以表明。因此,在出版物中,特别是在诉讼中,蔑视共同作者是不正确的。相反,研究结果表明,科学政策过程中的科学作者的一致性的直接测试。

英文摘要:

This paper focuses on the coauthor effect in different types of publications, usually not equally respected in measuring research impact. {\it A priori} unexpected relationships are found between the total coauthor core value, $m_a$, of a leading investigator (LI), and the related values for their publications in either peer review journals ($j$) or in proceedings ($p$). A surprisingly linear relationship is found: $ m_a^{(j)} + 0.4\;m_a^{(p)} = m_a^{(jp)} $. Furthermore, another relationship is found concerning the measure of the total number of citations, $A_a$, i.e. the surface of the citation size-rank histogram up to $m_a$. Another linear relationship exists : $A_a^{(j)} + 1.36\; A_a^{(p)} = A_a^{(jp)} $. These empirical findings coefficients (0.4 and 1.36) are supported by considerations based on an empirical power law found between the number of joint publications of an author and the rank of a coauthor. Moreover, a simple power law relationship is found between $m_a$ and the number ($r_M$) of coauthors of a LI: $m_a\simeq r_M^μ$; the power law exponent $μ$ depends on the type ($j$ or $p$) of publications. These simple relations, at this time limited to publications in physics, imply that coauthors are a "more positive measure" of a principal investigator role, in both types of scientific outputs, than the Hirsch index could indicate. Therefore, to scorn upon co-authors in publications, in particular in proceedings, is incorrect. On the contrary, the findings suggest an immediate test of coherence of scientific authorship in scientific policy processes.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑