三只小猪和大灰狼:同行评议的案例研究
The Three Little Pigs and the Big Bad Wolf: Case Studies of Peer Review
摘要:
我为您提供三个独立的案例,由一家受人尊敬的同行评审科学期刊进行手稿评审过程。每一个案例都涉及到一只小猪,他提交了一份关于在遥远的土地上建造一座房子的理论计划供考虑。该杂志指派了一位匿名的大坏狼来评估这些手稿的优点。猪提出了三种不同的构造框架,它们在物理和数学复杂性上各不相同。第一只小猪提交了一个稻草模型,基于脚趾计数的数字方法。他的设计包括一些奇怪的特征,比如洒在窗台上的小米和偶蹄印--可能是一种策略,以分散狼对手稿简单数学基础的注意力。第二只小猪采用了一种更先进的方法,运用牛顿的经典运动定律,提出了一个木棍屋。这只猪在她的手稿中大量引用了一只特定的狼,可能是为了通过奉承她预期将成为裁判的狼来确保接受。第三只小猪描述了一个基于复杂的动力系统和稳定性分析的华丽的砖房,可能是为了让人眼花缭乱。大灰狼似乎对猪的任何战术都不为所动。他的建议是,对于稻草:对防水性进行轻微修改;对于棍棒:考虑到对气候变化的担忧,对防火性进行重大修改;对于砖:明确拒绝,并伴随着对"高高在上的理论家"的多次贬损。“我详细描述了每一个案例,并建议狼的报告可能与手稿本身一样受到自身利益的驱使,也就是说,在狼写评论的时候,他很饿。最后,我检查道德教训,如果有的话。
英文摘要:
I present for your appraisal three independent cases of the manuscript referee process conducted by a venerable peer-reviewed scientific journal. Each case involves a little pig, who submitted for consideration a theoretical plan for a house to be constructed presently, in a faraway land. An anonymous big bad wolf was assigned by the journal to assess the merit of these manuscripts. The pigs proposed three distinct construction frameworks, which varied in physical and mathematical sophistication. The first little pig submitted a model of straw, based on the numerical method of toe-counting. His design included odd features, such as spilled millet and cloven-hoofprints on the window sill -- possibly a ploy to distract the wolf from the manuscript's facile mathematical foundation. The second little pig used a more advanced approach, employing Newton's classical laws of motion, to propose a house of sticks. This pig included in her manuscript copious citations by a specific wolf, possibly aiming to ensure acceptance by flattering the wolf whom she anticipated would be the referee. The third little pig described an ostentatious house of bricks based on an elaborate dynamical systems and stability analysis, possibly scheming to dazzle and impress. The big bad wolf did not appear moved by any of the pigs' tactics. His recommendations were, for straw: the minor revision of water-proofing; for sticks: the major revision of fire-proofing, given concerns surrounding climate change; for bricks: unequivocal rejection, accompanied by multiple derogatory comments regarding "high-and-mighty theorists." I describe each case in detail, and suggest that the wolf's reports might be driven as much by self interest as the manuscripts themselves -- namely, that at the time the wolf wrote the reviews, he was rather hungry. Finally, I examine morals learned, if any.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。