These comments were prepared during the ICFA Seminar on "Future Persrectives in High Energy Physics" held at CERN (8-11 October 2002) and partially presented at the Panel and General Discussion on Interregional Collaboration for Future Facilities (10 October). Comments include arguments favoring the existence of the fourth SM family and new level of compositness. Then, the possible role of the linac-ring type colliders for future HEP research is discussed emphasizing TeV scale lepton-hadron and photon-hadron colliders. This preprint presents prepared transparencies and some illuminating remarks with corresponding references.
Remarks on: `Theory of Neutrino Oscillations' (hep-ph/0311241) by C.Giunti, the comments by L.B.Okun et al in hep-ph/0312151, and Giunti's reply in hep-ph/0312180
Comment on arXiv:1408.0288v2 [hep-ph] and Phys. Rev. D 90, 085017 (2014), "A new evaluation of the antiproton production cross section for cosmic ray studies", Mattia di Mauro et al
Comment on the paper: ``Feynman-Schwinger representation approach to nonperturbative physics'' by C. Savkli et al. [Phys. Rev. C 60, 055210 (1999), hep-ph/9906211]
Comments on "Observation of Long-Range, Near-Side Angular Correlations in Proton-Proton Collisions at the LHC" by the CMS collaboration(arXiv:1009.4122v1 [hep-ex])"
Comment on "Mass and Width of the Lowest Resonance in QCD"
I. Caprini's,G. Colangelo's和H. Leutwyler(CCL)的文章“QCD中最低共振的质量和宽度”,物理评论Lett。96,132001(2006)[hep-ph/0512364]进行了批判性综述。本文的评论致力于补充最近的实验讨论(D. V. Bugg,J.Phys.G34,151(2007)[hep-ph/0608081])中的CCL分析中的短周期,通过提出理论论据,指出CCL使用的理论形式主义中的严重缺陷,以及他们在σ介子质量和宽度方面的微小误差条的不相似性。在评论中所作的批评适用于类似的分析卡帕介子质量进行的文章“K 0 *(800)标量共振从罗伊-施泰纳表示的π K散射”发表为S。Descotes-Genon和B. Moussallam,Eur. J. C 48,553(2006)[hep-ph/0607133]。
Comments on "Vacuum Birefringence in a Rotating Magnetic Field" [S. L. Adler, J. Phys. A40 (2007) F143-F152] and "The Rotation of magnetic field does not impact vacuum birefringence" [S. Biswas and K. Melnikov, Phys. Rev. D75 (2007) 053003]
关于S的2条评论的汇编。L. Adler,“Vacuum Biopolymers in a Rotating磁场“,J.Phys. A40(2007)F143-F152,hep-ph/0611267和S. Biswas和K. Melnikov,“The Rotation of磁场does not impact vacuum birefringence”,Phys.Rev.D75(2007)053003,hep-ph/0611345,希望它有一些用处。
Comment on Papers by Foot, Kobakhidze, McDonald and Volkas Relating to Scale Invariance Symmetry
我们指出,Foot等人在arXiv:0706.1829 [hep-ph]和arXiv:0709.2750 [hep-ph]中描述的工作是我们在arXiv:hep-th/0403039中描述的工作的衍生物,其扩展版本发表在“标准模型和SU(5)GUT with Local Scale Invariance and the Weylon”,AIP Conf.Proc.881(2007)pp. 82,Melville,New York,2006.我们想知道有多少动议(和出版物!)他们将经历,然后才最终承认他们重新发现了我们的模式,当然,正如这些天的通常做法,事后向全世界声称他们独立地到达了我们的模式。参考我们的原始工作是早就应该。
Comment on the Comment on the paper "Can oscillating neutrino states be formulated universally?''
最近,我们的工作有关的定义振荡中微子态的Eur。Phys. J. C 80:68(2020),arxiv:1902.01232 [hep-ph]已在arXiv:2004.04739 [hep-ph]中进行了评论。在这份说明中,我们表明,与评论中的要求相反,我们的上述工作不能在评论中描述的所谓风味Fock空间方法的方案中重现。此外,我们明确地证明了味Fock空间不能存在于一个模型与大量的混合中微子。如果味福克空间方案是可行的,它必然会导致,作为科尔曼定理的结果,混合中微子场的哈密顿量的味数不变性,而哈密顿量是由建设味数违反。这是荒谬的。
Lamm, Valluri, Jentschura and Weniger comment on "A Convergent Series for the QED Effective Action" by Cho and Pak [Phys. Rev. Lett. vol. 86, pp. 1947-1950 (2001)]
我们在[Can.]中获得了完整的结果。J. Phys. 71,389(1993)]的收敛级数表示的实部和虚部的QED有效作用量;这些推导是基于正确的中间步骤。在这篇评论中,我们认为,“对数校正项”的物理意义发现的Cho和Pak在[Phys. Rev. Lett. 86,1947(2001)]与通常的表达相比,QED的有效作用仍有待证明。有关相关受试者的更多信息见hep-ph/0308223的附录A和hep-th/0210240。
Comment on "Applications of Two-Body Dirac Equations to the Meson Spectrum with Three versus Two Covariant Interactions, SU(3) Mixing, and Comparison to a Quasipotential Approach'' by H. W. Crater and J. Schiermeyer
Comments on "Unified neutrino mixing and approximate $μ-τ$ reflection symmetry" (Mod. Phys. Lett. A, 40 (2025) 26, 2550097 [arXiv:2502.18029 [hep-ph]])
CAS Key Laboratory of Theoretical Physics, Institute of Theoretical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences(中国科学院理论物理研究所);Physics school, Henan Normal University(河南师范大学物理学院)