arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv cs/0612005cs.HC
收藏

同行评议会议中参与者角色影响的定量测量

Quantitative Measurements of the Influence of Participant Roles during Peer Review Meetings

Patrick D'Astous, Pierre Robillard, Françoise Détienne, Willemien Visser

摘要:

同行评审会议(PRM)是正式的会议,在此期间同行系统地分析工件以提高其质量并报告不符合项。本文提出了一种基于协议分析的方法,用于量化PRM过程中参与者角色的影响。三个视图用于描述七个定义的参与者角色。项目视图定义了三个角色:监督者、过程专家和开发者。会议视图定义了两个角色:作者和评审者,任务视图定义了反映对评审中的工件的直接和间接兴趣的角色。基于对数线性模型的分析表明,审查活动有不同的模式,这取决于他们的重点:形式或内容。每个角色的影响进行了分析,就这个焦点。定量数据的解释导致的建议,PRM可以通过创建三种不同类型的审查,其中每一个收集在一起的特定角色:形式审查,认知同步审查和内容审查。

英文摘要:

Peer review meetings (PRMs) are formal meetings during which peers systematically analyze artifacts to improve their quality and report on non-conformities. This paper presents an approach based on protocol analysis for quantifying the influence of participant roles during PRMs. Three views are used to characterize the seven defined participant roles. The project view defines three roles supervisor, procedure expert and developer. The meeting view defines two roles: author and reviewer, and the task view defines the roles reflecting direct and indirect interest in the artifact under review. The analysis, based on log-linear modeling, shows that review activities have different patterns, depending on their focus: form or content. The influence of each role is analyzed with respect to this focus. Interpretation of the quantitative data leads to the suggestion that PRMs could be improved by creating three different types of reviews, each of which collects together specific roles: form review, cognitive synchronization review and content review.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑