arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2602.00139econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

薪酬转提示:企业层面关于劳动与人工智能替代的证据

Payrolls to Prompts: Firm-Level Evidence on the Substitution of Labor for AI

Ramp

Ryan Stevens

AI总结:

本文通过企业层面的数据,研究生成式AI如何替代人类劳动,发现高暴露企业采用AI更积极,同时减少劳动支出,实现显著成本节约。

摘要:

生成式人工智能有潜力改变企业生产输出的方式。然而,关于人工智能实际上如何替代人类劳动力的可信证据仍然有限。本文研究了企业层面在线劳动与生成式人工智能之间的替代关系,使用了来自大型美国费用管理平台的付款数据。我们跟踪了2021年第三季度至2025年第三季度在线劳动市场(如Upwork和Fiverr)和领先AI模型提供商上的季度支出。为了识别因果效应,我们利用2022年10月ChatGPT的发布作为共同采用冲击,并估计一个差异-差异模型。我们提供了一个基于冲击前在线劳动市场支出份额的新颖暴露指标。暴露于在线劳动较多的企业在冲击后更早且更积极地采用AI,同时减少合同劳动支出。到2025年第三季度,最高暴露四分位数的企业相比最低暴露四分位数的企业,将AI模型提供商的支出份额增加了0.8个百分点,同时劳动市场支出显著下降。将这些反应结合起来,得到替代的直接估计:对于最暴露的企业,在线劳动支出每减少1美元,就与额外的AI支出约0.03美元相关,意味着用AI服务替代外包任务可获得数量级的成本节省。这些效应在企业间异质,并随时间逐渐显现。总体而言,我们的结果提供了首个直接、微观层面的证据,表明生成式人工智能正在被用作生产中的部分人类劳动力替代品。

英文摘要:

Generative AI has the potential to transform how firms produce output. Yet, credible evidence on how AI is actually substituting for human labor remains limited. In this paper, we study firm-level substitution between contracted online labor and generative AI using payments data from a large U.S. expense management platform. We track quarterly spending from Q3 2021 to Q3 2025 on online labor marketplaces (such as Upwork and Fiverr) and leading AI model providers. To identify causal effects, we exploit the October 2022 release of ChatGPT as a common adoption shock and estimate a difference-in-differences model. We provide a novel measure of exposure based on the share of spending at online labor marketplaces prior to the shock. Firms with greater exposure to online labor adopt AI earlier and more intensively following the shock, while simultaneously reducing spending on contracted labor. By Q3 2025, firms in the highest exposure quartile increase their share of spending on AI model providers by 0.8 percentage points relative to the lowest exposure quartile, alongside significant declines in labor marketplace spending. Combining these responses yields a direct estimate of substitution: among the most exposed firms, a \$1 decline in online labor spending is associated with approximately \$0.03 of additional AI spending, implying order-of-magnitude cost savings from replacing outsourced tasks with AI services. These effects are heterogeneous across firms and emerge gradually over time. Taken together, our results provide the first direct, micro-level evidence that generative AI is being used as a partial substitute for human labor in production.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑