arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2407.17481cs.CY
收藏

人工智能的人类监督与技术标准化

Human Oversight of Artificial Intelligence and Technical Standardisation

Marion Ho-Dac, Baptiste Martinez

AI总结:

本文探讨了在欧盟AI Act等多层次监管背景下,法律与技术标准在塑造AI系统人类监督轮廓时的差异,强调法学专家对确保监督有效性与AI可信度的监管治理的贡献。

摘要:

采取人类监督措施使得能够以不同程度和不同方式对人工智能(AI)系统的决策过程进行监管,例如安排人员负责监督该系统,并在上游开发AI系统时使其具备实现此类监督的能力。在AI的全球治理中,人类监督的要求体现在多种规范来源中的若干监管格式中。一方面,它加强了AI系统用户的责任(例如,要求他们执行某些检查),另一方面,它更好地保护了受基于AI的决策影响的个人(例如,允许他们请求对该决策进行审查)。在欧洲背景下,AI Act对高风险AI系统的提供者(以及在某种程度上对这些被称为部署者的专业用户)施加了义务,包括在AI系统的整个生命周期中引入人类监督工具,包括通过设计(以及由部署者实施)。因此,欧盟立法者在“详细说明”人类监督的法律要求方面比过去走得远得多。但它并不打算规定所有的实施细节;它呼吁在AI Act第40条的基础上,通过标准化在技术上充实这一要求(以及更广泛地,第III章第2节的所有要求)。在这种多层次的监管背景下,应特别关注人类在AI决策过程中的地位问题。事实上,取决于是由法律还是由技术标准来设定人类监督的轮廓,AI的“监管治理”是不同的:其性质、内容和范围都有所不同。这一分析是法学专家对确保人类监督的有效性和AI可信度的最合适的监管治理——就其制度格式和实质而言——的核心反思所做出(或将做出)的贡献的核心。

英文摘要:

The adoption of human oversight measures makes it possible to regulate, to varying degrees and in different ways, the decision-making process of Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems, for example by placing a human being in charge of supervising the system and, upstream, by developing the AI system to enable such supervision. Within the global governance of AI, the requirement for human oversight is embodied in several regulatory formats, within a diversity of normative sources. On the one hand, it reinforces the accountability of AI systems' users (for example, by requiring them to carry out certain checks) and, on the other hand, it better protects the individuals affected by the AI-based decision (for example, by allowing them to request a review of the decision). In the European context, the AI Act imposes obligations on providers of high-risk AI systems (and to some extent also on professional users of these systems, known as deployers), including the introduction of human oversight tools throughout the life cycle of AI systems, including by design (and their implementation by deployers). The EU legislator is therefore going much further than in the past in "spelling out" the legal requirement for human oversight. But it does not intend to provide for all implementation details; it calls on standardisation to technically flesh out this requirement (and more broadly all the requirements of section 2 of chapter III) on the basis of article 40 of the AI Act. In this multi-level regulatory context, the question of the place of humans in the AI decision-making process should be given particular attention. Indeed, depending on whether it is the law or the technical standard that sets the contours of human oversight, the "regulatory governance" of AI is not the same: its nature, content and scope are different. This analysis is at the heart of the contribution made (or to be made) by legal experts to the central reflection on the most appropriate regulatory governance -- in terms of both its institutional format and its substance -- to ensure the effectiveness of human oversight and AI trustworthiness.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑