arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2407.01077cs.HC
收藏

社会关系对电子学习中同伴评估的影响

Impact of Social Relationships on Peer Assessment in E-Learning

Francisco Sousa, Tomás Alves, Sandra Gama, Joaquim Jorge, Daniel Gonçalves

AI总结:

本文通过 Moodle 插件在 MSc 课程论坛中开展同伴评估,发现既有社会关系会造成个别评分偏差,但至少三次评估可保证可靠准确,且对最终汇总成绩影响很小。

摘要:

同伴评估作为传统评价的替代方式已得到广泛研究,它不仅能减轻教授的工作量,更主要的是能促进学生的参与和学习。尽管已有若干研究成功验证了其准确性和公平性,但关于学生既有的社会关系如何影响他们在电子学习课程中给同伴的评分,仍需开展更多研究。我们开发了一个 Moodle 插件,使该平台能够在论坛中提供同伴评估功能,并在一门理学硕士(MSc)课程中使用了它。该插件根据作者的关系为一篇帖子筛选评审者集合,并纳入评分量规,以抵消同伴评估可能产生的人际影响。结果证实,对于至少接受三次同伴评估的作品,同伴评估是可靠且准确的,尽管学生给出的分数略高。当不喜欢某位同伴的学生对其作品给出的评分始终低于与该同伴具有积极关系的学生时,社会关系的影响十分明显。然而,这对最终汇总的同伴评分几乎没有影响。我们的研究结果表明,在学生彼此熟悉的电子学习环境中,同伴评估可以取代传统评价。

英文摘要:

Peer assessment has been widely studied as a replacement for traditional evaluation, not only by reducing the professors' workload but mainly by benefiting students' engagement and learning. Although several works successfully validate its accuracy and fairness, more research must be done on how students' pre-existing social relationships affect the grades they give their peers in an e-learning course. We developed a Moodle plugin to provide the platform with peer assessment capabilities in forums and used it on an MSc course. The plugin curated the reviewer set for a post based on the author's relationships and included rubrics to counter the possible interpersonal effects of peer assessment. Results confirm that peer assessment is reliable and accurate for works with at least three peer assessments, although students' grades are slightly higher. The impact of social relationships is noticeable when students who do not like another peer grade their work consistently lower than students who have a positive connection. However, this has little influence on the final aggregate peer grade. Our findings show that peer assessment can replace traditional evaluation in an e-learning environment where students are familiar with each other.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑