Peer assessment has been widely studied as a replacement for traditional evaluation, not only by reducing the professors' workload but mainly by benefiting students' engagement and learning. Although several works successfully validate its accuracy and fairness, more research must be done on how students' pre-existing social relationships affect the grades they give their peers in an e-learning course. We developed a Moodle plugin to provide the platform with peer assessment capabilities in forums and used it on an MSc course. The plugin curated the reviewer set for a post based on the author's relationships and included rubrics to counter the possible interpersonal effects of peer assessment. Results confirm that peer assessment is reliable and accurate for works with at least three peer assessments, although students' grades are slightly higher. The impact of social relationships is noticeable when students who do not like another peer grade their work consistently lower than students who have a positive connection. However, this has little influence on the final aggregate peer grade. Our findings show that peer assessment can replace traditional evaluation in an e-learning environment where students are familiar with each other.
AI Peers Exert Social Influence on Human Dishonesty in Groups
Tsinghua University(清华大学);Beijing Normal University(北京师范大学);China University of Political Science and Law(中国政法大学);National University of Singapore(新加坡国立大学);Zhejiang University(浙江大学)
本研究通过两项随机实验发现,AI 同伴对群体中人类不诚实行为的影响与人类同伴相当,且不诚实规范线索会显著增加不诚实报告,强调了管理 AI 群体成员行为信号的重要性。
A Comparative Analysis of Peer Support in Forum-based and Chat-based Mental Health Communities: Technical-Structural-Functional Model of Social Support