arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2406.02028stat.ME
收藏

带有基线期的平行整群随机试验应如何分析?估计目标与常用估计量的综述

How should parallel cluster randomized trials with a baseline period be analyzed? A survey of estimands and common estimators

Kenneth Menglin Lee, Fan Li

AI总结:

本文在具有信息性群集规模的PB-CRT中定义了pATE和cATE两个估计目标,理论推导了四种常用估计量的收敛性,发现独立性估计方程和固定效应模型一致,且可交换混合效应模型对偏差具有意外稳健性。

摘要:

带有基线期的平行整群随机试验(PB-CRT)是标准平行整群随机试验(P-CRT)的常见变体。我们在具有信息性群集规模的 PB-CRT 背景下定义了两个自然的估计目标,即参与者平均处理效应(pATE)和群集平均处理效应(cATE),以解决参与者和群集层面的假设。在本研究中,我们在理论上推导了在具有连续结果的 PB-CRT 中,未加权和按群集-周期规模倒数加权的以下方法的处理效应估计量的收敛性:独立性估计方程、固定效应模型、可交换混合效应模型和嵌套可交换混合效应模型。总体而言,我们在理论上表明,未加权和加权的独立性估计方程以及固定效应模型为 pATE 和 cATE 估计目标提供了一致的估计量。尽管在信息性群集规模下,混合效应模型对这两个自然估计目标提供了不一致的估计量,但我们凭经验证明,可交换混合效应模型对偏差具有令人惊讶的稳健性。这与 P-CRT 中的相应分析以及 PB-CRT 中的嵌套可交换混合效应模型形成鲜明对比,并可能对实践产生影响。我们报告了一项模拟研究,最后对一项 PB-CRT 进行了再分析,该试验研究社区青年团队对改善印度东部农村青少年女孩心理健康的影响。

英文摘要:

The parallel cluster randomized trial with baseline (PB-CRT) is a common variant of the standard parallel cluster randomized trial (P-CRT). We define two natural estimands in the context of PB-CRTs with informative cluster sizes, the participant-average treatment effect (pATE) and cluster-average treatment effect (cATE), to address participant and cluster-level hypotheses. In this work, we theoretically derive the convergence of the unweighted and inverse cluster-period size weighted (i.) independence estimating equation, (ii.) fixed-effects model, (iii.) exchangeable mixed-effects model, and (iv.) nested-exchangeable mixed-effects model treatment effect estimators in a PB-CRT with continuous outcomes. Overall, we theoretically show that the unweighted and weighted independence estimating equation and fixed-effects model yield consistent estimators for the pATE and cATE estimands. Although mixed-effects models yield inconsistent estimators to these two natural estimands under informative cluster sizes, we empirically demonstrate that the exchangeable mixed-effects model is surprisingly robust to bias. This is in sharp contrast to the corresponding analyses in P-CRTs and the nested-exchangeable mixed-effects model in PB-CRTs, and may carry implications for practice. We report a simulation study and conclude with a re-analysis of a PB-CRT examining the effects of community youth teams on improving mental health among adolescent girls in rural eastern India.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑