To precisely define the treatment effect of interest in a clinical trial, the ICH E9 estimand addendum describes that relevant so-called intercurrent events should be identified and strategies specified to deal with them. Handling intercurrent events with different strategies leads to different estimands. In this paper, we focus on estimands that involve addressing one intercurrent event with the treatment policy strategy and another with the hypothetical strategy. We define these estimands using potential outcomes and causal diagrams, considering the possible causal relationships between the two intercurrent events and other variables. We show that there are different causal estimand definitions and assumptions one could adopt, each having different implications for estimation, which is demonstrated in a simulation study. The different considerations are illustrated conceptually using a diabetes trial as an example.
Hypothetical estimands in clinical trials: a unification of causal inference and missing data methods
ICH E9附录引入了术语并发事件,是指随机化后发生的事件,这些事件可能妨碍观察到关注的结局或影响其解释。它提出了五种处理并发事件的策略,以形成一个被估量,但没有提出估计的统计方法。在本文中,我们专注于假设的策略,其中的处理效应的假设情况下,其中并发事件是防止定义。对于它的估计,我们考虑了因果推断和缺失数据方法。我们建立了某些“因果推断估计量”是相同的某些“缺失数据估计量”。这些链接可能会帮助那些熟悉一套方法而不是另一套方法的人。此外,使用潜在结果符号使我们能够更清楚地说明缺失数据方法依赖于哪些假设来估计假设被估量。这有助于表明估计假设的被估量是否合理,以及在分析中应该使用什么数据。我们发现,假设的被估量可以估计并发事件发生后,这是通常不使用的数据利用。我们还提出了蒙特卡罗模拟,说明在不同的设置中的方法的实施和性能。
Applying the estimands framework to non-inferiority trials: guidance on choice of hypothetical estimands for non-adherence and comparison of estimation methods
Living forwards or understanding backwards? A comparison of Inverse Probability of Treatment Weighting and G-estimation methods for targeting hypothetical full adherence estimands in longitudinal cohort studies
University of Exeter(埃克塞特大学);Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust(皇家德文郡大学医疗保健NHS基金会信托);Novo Nordisk Research Centre (NNRCO)(诺和诺德研究中心)
Dealing with positivity violations in mediation analysis via weighted controlled effects, with application to assessing immune correlates of protection in antigen-experienced participants
Department of Statistics, University of Washington(华盛顿大学统计学系);Vaccine and Infectious Disease Division, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center(弗雷德·哈钦森癌症中心疫苗与传染病部)
Estimands and their Estimators for Clinical Trials Impacted by the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Report from the NISS Ingram Olkin Forum Series on Unplanned Clinical Trial Disruptions