arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2403.17248stat.AP
收藏

法医枪支比对每一项黑盒研究中的方法论问题

Methodological Problems in Every Black-Box Study of Forensic Firearm Comparisons

Maria Cuellar, Susan Vanderplas, Amanda Luby, Michael Rosenblum

AI总结:

本文评估了法医枪支比对领域所有“黑盒”研究的方法,指出其均存在严重缺陷导致无法确立该领域的科学有效性,且检验员的错误率仍未知,并为未来研究提供了设计与分析建议。

摘要:

由美国国家科学院(2009年)和科技顾问委员会(2016年)进行的审查得出结论,法医枪支比对领域尚未被证明具有科学有效性。科学有效性要求对枪支检验员的准确性、可重复性和可复现性表现进行充分设计的研究。研究人员已经开展了“黑盒”研究,旨在估计这些性能指标。作为在实验设计方面具有专业知识的统计学家,我们对迄今为止的此类研究进行了文献检索,随后评估了每项研究所使用的设计和统计分析方法。我们的结论是,我们文献检索中的所有研究都存在极其严重的方法论缺陷,以至于这些研究是无效的,即无法确立枪支检验领域的科学有效性。值得注意的是,枪支检验员的错误率,无论是总体还是个体,仍然未知。因此,基于对“个体”特征的检验而作出的关于子弹或弹壳同源的陈述没有科学依据。我们为未来研究的设计和分析提供了一些建议。

英文摘要:

Reviews conducted by the National Academy of Sciences (2009) and the President's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (2016) concluded that the field of forensic firearm comparisons has not been demonstrated to be scientifically valid. Scientific validity requires adequately designed studies of firearm examiner performance in terms of accuracy, repeatability, and reproducibility. Researchers have performed ``black-box'' studies with the goal of estimating these performance measures. As statisticians with expertise in experimental design, we conducted a literature search of such studies to date and then evaluated the design and statistical analysis methods used in each study. Our conclusion is that all studies in our literature search have methodological flaws that are so grave that they render the studies invalid, that is, incapable of establishing scientific validity of the field of firearms examination. Notably, error rates among firearms examiners, both collectively and individually, remain unknown. Therefore, statements about the common origin of bullets or cartridge cases that are based on examination of ``individual" characteristics do not have a scientific basis. We provide some recommendations for the design and analysis of future studies.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑