揭示法医黑箱研究
Shining a Light on Forensic Black-Box Studies
AI总结:
本文针对法医黑箱研究中抽样不具代表性与数据缺失不可忽略的问题,利用现有研究和法庭数据证明其会低估错误率,并提出改进步骤。
摘要:
法医科学在美国刑事司法系统中发挥着关键作用。数十年来,许多基于特征的法医科学领域,如枪支和工具痕迹鉴定,是在科学界视野之外发展起来的。这些研究的结果被全美各地的法官广泛依赖。然而,这种依赖是不恰当的。迄今为止的黑箱研究存在抽样方法不当和缺失率高的问题。当前的黑箱研究在得出提交给法庭的错误率估计值时,忽视了这两个问题。我们利用黑箱研究和法庭材料中的可用数据,探讨了每类局限的影响。我们表明,黑箱研究依赖于不具代表性的检验人员样本。通过对一项广为使用的弹道学研究进行案例分析,我们发现有证据表明,这些不具代表性的样本所犯错误可能少于其来源的更广泛总体。我们还发现证据表明,黑箱研究中的数据缺失具有不可忽略性。利用近期一项潜在指纹研究的数据,我们表明忽视这种缺失很可能导致对错误率的系统性低估。最后,我们提出了克服这些局限的具体步骤。
英文摘要:
Forensic science plays a critical role in the United States criminal justice system. For decades, many feature-based fields of forensic science, such as firearm and toolmark identification, developed outside the scientific community's purview. The results of these studies are widely relied on by judges nationwide. However, this reliance is misplaced. Black-box studies to date suffer from inappropriate sampling methods and high rates of missingness. Current black-box studies ignore both problems in arriving at the error rate estimates presented to courts. We explore the impact of each type of limitation using available data from black-box studies and court materials. We show that black-box studies rely on non-representative samples of examiners. Using a case study of a popular ballistics study, we find evidence that these unrepresentative samples may commit fewer errors than the wider population from which they came. We also find evidence that the missingness in black-box studies is non-ignorable. Using data from a recent latent print study, we show that ignoring this missingness likely results in systematic underestimates of error rates. Finally, we offer concrete steps to overcome these limitations.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。