火器比较的准确性、重复性和再现性第1部分:准确性
Accuracy, Repeatability, and Reproducibility of Firearm Comparisons Part 1: Accuracy
摘要:
埃姆斯法医局-美国能源部和联邦调查局(FBI)的研究人员进行了一项研究,以评估法医在枪支调查中的表现。这项研究涉及三种不同类型的枪支和173名志愿者,他们比较了子弹和弹壳。报告的比较总数为20,130,分配用于评估参与检查员所做评估的准确性(8,640),重复性(5,700)和再现性(5,790)。子弹和弹壳的总体假阳性错误率估计分别为0.656%和0.933%,而子弹和弹壳的假阴性率估计分别为2.87%和1.87%。由于卡方检验的独立性强烈表明,错误概率是不相同的每个检查员,这些是最大似然估计的基础上β-二项式概率模型,并不依赖于一个假设,平等的检查员特定的错误率。对应的95%置信区间分别为:子弹和弹壳的假阳性为(0.305%,1.42%)和(0.548%,1.57%),子弹和弹壳的假阴性为(1.89%,4.26%)和(1.16%,2.99%)。这些结果是基于代表所考虑的所有受控条件的数据,包括不同的枪支制造商,制造顺序,以及未知和已知比较样本之间的射击间隔。结果与先前的研究结果一致,尽管其设计更稳健,样本更具挑战性。
英文摘要:
Researchers at the Ames Laboratory-USDOE and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) conducted a study to assess the performance of forensic examiners in firearm investigations. The study involved three different types of firearms and 173 volunteers who compared both bullets and cartridge cases. The total number of comparisons reported is 20,130, allocated to assess accuracy (8,640), repeatability (5,700), and reproducibility (5,790) of the evaluations made by participating examiners. The overall false positive error rate was estimated as 0.656% and 0.933% for bullets and cartridge cases, respectively, while the rate of false negatives was estimated as 2.87% and 1.87% for bullets and cartridge cases, respectively. Because chi-square tests of independence strongly suggest that error probabilities are not the same for each examiner, these are maximum likelihood estimates based on the beta-binomial probability model and do not depend on an assumption of equal examiner-specific error rates. Corresponding 95% confidence intervals are (0.305%,1.42%) and (0.548%,1.57%) for false positives for bullets and cartridge cases, respectively, and (1.89%,4.26%) and (1.16%,2.99%) for false negatives for bullets and cartridge cases, respectively. These results are based on data representing all controlled conditions considered, including different firearm manufacturers, sequence of manufacture, and firing separation between unknown and known comparison specimens. The results are consistent with those of prior studies, despite its more robust design and challenging specimens.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。