arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2401.01809stat.AP
收藏

分类专家证人陈述的证据强度

Evidential strength of categorical expert witness statements

Rolf JF Ypma

AI总结:

本文提出一种利用大规模性能研究数据计算法医分类专家证人陈述似然比(LR)的简单方法,涵盖指纹、笔迹等领域,发现所得LR值比预期更接近1,并提醒应将其视为估算值。

摘要:

在许多司法管辖区,法医证据以法医专家的分类陈述形式呈现。已经进行了几项大规模性能研究,报告了错误率,以阐明与这些分类陈述相关的不确定性。越来越多的科学共识认为,似然比(LR)框架是法医证据评估在逻辑上正确的呈现形式。然而,大规模性能研究的结果尚未被纳入这一框架。在此,我展示了如何使用性能研究的数据,直接为任何给定的分类陈述计算 LR。这个数字量化了当我们获得特定的专家证人陈述时,我们应该在多大程度上相信同源假设而非异源假设。本文报告了由潜在指纹、血迹形态、笔迹、鞋印和枪支分析得出的分类陈述的 LR。对于识别陈述,发现的最高 LR 为 376(指纹);对于排除陈述,发现的最低 LR 为 1/28(笔迹)。对于习惯使用该框架的人来说,所发现的 LR 可能比之前报告的各种错误率更具洞察力。以这种方式使用 LR 的另一个额外优势是相对简单;无需决定关注哪种错误率或如何处理无法得出结论的陈述。所发现的数值比许多人预期的更接近 1。对这种不匹配的一种可能解释是我们低估了数值 LR。最后,提醒注意:本文报告的 LR 值来自简单的计算,未能充分体现大规模研究及其与实际案件工作差异的细微之处,应将其视为大致估计值,而非对整个法医学领域证据价值的最终定论。

英文摘要:

In many jurisdictions, forensic evidence is presented in the form of categorical statements by forensic experts. Several large-scale performance studies have been performed that report error rates to elucidate the uncertainty associated with such categorical statements. There is growing scientific consensus that the likelihood ratio (LR) framework is the logically correct form of presentation for forensic evidence evaluation. Yet, results from the large-scale performance studies have not been cast in this framework. Here, I show how to straightforwardly calculate an LR for any given categorical statement using data from the performance studies. This number quantifies how much more we should believe the hypothesis of same source vs different source, when provided a particular expert witness statement. LRs are reported for categorical statements resulting from the analysis of latent fingerprints, bloodstain patterns, handwriting, footwear and firearms. The highest LR found for statements of identification was 376 (fingerprints), the lowest found for statements of exclusion was 1/28 (handwriting). The LRs found may be more insightful for those used to this framework than the various error rates reported previously. An additional advantage of using the LR in this way is the relative simplicity; there are no decisions necessary on what error rate to focus on or how to handle inconclusive statements. The values found are closer to 1 than many would have expected. One possible explanation for this mismatch is that we undervalue numerical LRs. Finally, a note of caution: the LR values reported here come from a simple calculation that does not do justice to the nuances of the large-scale studies and their differences to casework, and should be treated as ball-park figures rather than definitive statements on the evidential value of whole forensic scientific fields.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑