arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2402.14540cs.GT
收藏

关于奖励最大化的真实物品获取机制研究

On Truthful Item-Acquiring Mechanisms for Reward Maximization

Liang Shan, Shuo Zhang, Jie Zhang, Zihe Wang

AI总结:

本文研究收藏家在所有者私有质量信息和评估噪声下获取物品的机制设计,分析菜单规模对期望奖励的影响,提出单物品最优机制及多物品Union机制,并实验验证其鲁棒性。

摘要:

在这项研究中,我们研究了一个问题:一位收藏家根据物品所有者声明的物品质量以及一位独立评估师的评估结果,从所有者处获取物品。所有者希望最大化收藏家获取物品的概率,并且是唯一知道物品真实质量的人。评估师公正地履行职责,但她的评估可能受到随机噪声的影响,因此可能无法准确反映物品的真实质量。主要挑战在于设计能够促使所有者披露准确信息的机制,从而优化收藏家的期望奖励。我们将机制的菜单规模作为其实用性的衡量标准,并研究其对可达到的期望奖励的影响。对于单物品场景,我们设计了具有单调递增菜单规模的最优机制。尽管最简单机制与最优机制之间的奖励差距是有界的,但我们证明,菜单规模较小的简单机制无法保证获得菜单规模较大机制最优奖励的任何正比例。对于多物品场景,我们证明仅以所有者对物品的排序作为输入的序数机制不具备激励相容性。随后,我们提出了一组将单物品机制组合起来的Union机制。此外,我们进行了实验,以检验这些机制对独立评估师评估准确性和物品获取率的鲁棒性。

英文摘要:

In this research, we study the problem that a collector acquires items from the owner based on the item qualities the owner declares and an independent appraiser's assessments. The owner is interested in maximizing the probability that the collector acquires the items and is the only one who knows the items' factual quality. The appraiser performs her duties with impartiality, but her assessment may be subject to random noises, so it may not accurately reflect the factual quality of the items. The main challenge lies in devising mechanisms that prompt the owner to reveal accurate information, thereby optimizing the collector's expected reward. We consider the menu size of mechanisms as a measure of their practicability and study its impact on the attainable expected reward. For the single-item setting, we design optimal mechanisms with a monotone increasing menu size. Although the reward gap between the simplest and optimal mechanisms is bounded, we show that simple mechanisms with a small menu size cannot ensure any positive fraction of the optimal reward of mechanisms with a larger menu size. For the multi-item setting, we show that an ordinal mechanism that only takes the owner's ordering of the items as input is not incentive-compatible. We then propose a set of Union mechanisms that combine single-item mechanisms. Moreover, we run experiments to examine these mechanisms' robustness against the independent appraiser's assessment accuracy and the items' acquiring rate.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑