arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2306.01211stat.MEstat.AP
收藏

实验设计中的启动偏差与处理后偏差

Priming bias versus post-treatment bias in experimental designs

Harvard University(哈佛大学);Boston University(波士顿大学);Waseda University(早稻田大学)

Matthew Blackwell, Jacob R. Brown, Sophie Hill, Kosuke Imai, Teppei Yamamoto

AI总结:

本文形式化分析了实验设计中调节变量测量时机引发的启动偏差与处理后偏差之间的权衡,推导了三种设计下交互效应的非参数界限,并将其应用于选举信息调查实验。

摘要:

在估计因果效应时,对受处理影响的变量进行条件化会引入处理后偏差。尽管这表明研究人员应在实验中实施处理之前测量潜在的调节变量,但如果协变量测量使受访者对处理产生不同的反应,这样做也可能使因果效应估计产生偏差。本文正式分析了在三种实验设计中处理后偏差与启动偏差之间的权衡,这三种设计根据调节变量的测量时机而有所不同:处理前测量、处理后测量,或在两者之间进行随机选择。我们针对每种设计推导了处理与调节变量之间交互效应的非参数界限,并展示了如何利用实质性假设来缩小这些界限。这些界限使研究人员能够评估其经验发现对启动偏差和处理后偏差的敏感性。随后,我们将所提出的方法应用于一项关于选举信息的调查实验。

英文摘要:

Conditioning on variables affected by treatment can induce post-treatment bias when estimating causal effects. Although this suggests that researchers should measure potential moderators before administering the treatment in an experiment, doing so may also bias causal effect estimation if the covariate measurement primes respondents to react differently to the treatment. This paper formally analyzes this trade-off between post-treatment and priming biases in three experimental designs that vary when moderators are measured: pre-treatment, post-treatment, or a randomized choice between the two. We derive nonparametric bounds for interactions between the treatment and the moderator under each design and show how to use substantive assumptions to narrow these bounds. These bounds allow researchers to assess the sensitivity of their empirical findings to priming and post-treatment bias. We then apply the proposed methodology to a survey experiment on electoral messaging.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑